Philosophy of Trash

Sunday, March 1, 2020
First Aired: 
Sunday, November 5, 2017

What Is It

"One man's trash is another man's treasure," or so the saying goes. But what makes something trash to begin with? The word can be used to describe disposable objects, pieces of culture, or even people. Underlying each of these uses, however, are feelings of indifference, disdain, or disgust. How do the things that we call trash reflect our values, as individuals, and as a society? What can we learn about ourselves by examining the things we deem worthy of throwing away? The Philosophers go dumpster diving with Elizabeth Spelman from Smith College, author of Trash Talks: Revelations in the Rubbish.

Listening Notes

Ken argues that the massive amount of trash that we produce is a necessary tradeoff to innovation. Not only is it natural for humans to want new things, but innovation requires that we abandon the old. Debra, on the other hand, invites Ken to distinguish between innovation and pointless consumption. She argues that the unbridled consumption in the West needs to slow, since the trash that it creates destroys the planet. Our hosts wonder if humans will need to reconsider what deserves to be thrown away to live more sustainably on the planet.

Ken and Debra are joined by Elizabeth (Vicky) Spelman, professor of Philosophy at Smith College. Vicky tells us that “garbage,” “waste,” and “trash” are not always synonymous. Instead, what makes something trash is our attitude toward the object in question. As for waste, Vicky introduces Thorstein Veblen’s concept of “conspicuous consumption” and “conspicuous waste” to the conversation. According to Veblen, elite classes flaunt their wastefulness as a show of their social status. The philosophers broaden their discussion to hyper-consumerism in the United States and how this contributes to the growing piles of trash in our landfills. They consider capitalism and corporations as additional contributors to hyper-consumerism itself.

The philosophers welcome callers’ comments and weigh human innovation as either a threat to the environment or asset to enhancing human quality of life. They consider humans’ proclivities for never having enough a tenet of this environmental and social issue.

  • Roving Philosophical Reporter (Seek to 6:19): Liza Veale interviews resident artists at Recology San Francisco, where artists use recycled materials from the San Francisco dump to create new art.

  • Sixty Second Philosopher  (Seek to 45:14): Ian Shoales reminds us that trash in earlier epochs become historical artifacts in newer ones.  

Transcript

Comments (6)


Harold G. Neuman's picture

Harold G. Neuman

Saturday, February 22, 2020 -- 12:34 PM

Built a wheelbarrow out of

Built a wheelbarrow out of parts once, Still using it---cost me about thirty-five dollars. Could have bought a new one for two or three times more, but, I did not need a new one---just one that would haul stuff. I save lots of money that way, and learn how to do things, in the bargain.

cherry elliott's picture

cherry elliott

Sunday, March 1, 2020 -- 12:05 PM

awesome rant on stuff, ian!

awesome rant on stuff, ian!

alexseen's picture

alexseen

Thursday, July 4, 2024 -- 4:26 AM

Our community center recently

Our community center recently hosted a large festival, and we had a lot of waste that needed to be cleared out quickly. I needed a service that could handle large volumes of waste on short notice. I found https://affordablewastemanagement.co.uk/commercial-waste-disposal/ and decided to give them a try. The website was very user-friendly, and I was able to get a quote within minutes. They offered various packages, including special rates for events, which was exactly what we needed. The crew arrived on time and did an excellent job managing all the waste. Their service was top-notch and very efficient, making the cleanup process much smoother for us.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Kevenorn's picture

Kevenorn

Wednesday, August 21, 2024 -- 8:10 PM

I previously spent about $35

I previously spent about $35 putting together a wheelbarrow out of scraps; I'm still using it. I could have spent twice as much on a brand new one, but I didn't want anything fancy; all I needed was a reliable vehicle for hauling my belongings. That way, not only do I learn how to do things, but I also save slope game a ton of money.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
coral's picture

coral

Wednesday, October 9, 2024 -- 12:42 PM

The best app to place bets on

The best app to place bets on the game online - https://melbetmn.app/> recently found this site and was delighted with it! it pleased me with its simplicity and reliability, it is always one to trust, it also has a beautiful interface and high-quality interesting games and I was also pleased that there is an application of this site on the phone, which is very useful when you are not at home!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Tolikam's picture

Tolikam

Sunday, October 20, 2024 -- 7:46 AM

As a newcomer to the world of

As a newcomer to the world of online casinos, I was pleasantly surprised by how convenient it is to play at
https://seoulworkers.kr/app/ Korean Casino. The interface is easy to use, even if you have no previous experience in such games. I would especially like to mention the support service - they quickly respond to any inquiries and help to solve any problems. The bonuses here are also very attractive - starting with the welcome package and ending with regular promotions. This casino really deserves attention as one of the best in Korea.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines