Money Matters

27 April 2020

Is money the root of all evil, or is it just a technology that makes our lives more efficient? Should some things not be for sale? This week on Philosophy Talk, we’ll be discussing money: where it comes from, what it is now, and what it could become in the future.

 

You might think that something counts as money just in case it’s a valuable commodity that everybody is willing to barter for. Some forms of money, like gold coins, certainly fit this description. Others, like deeds that entitle the bearer to gold, are valuable because they represent valuable commodities. But it’s common for money to be backed not by a valuable commodity, but by fiat—that is, a declaration by a central bank which says that it’s valuable.

 

According to another view, known as neo-chartalism, it’s the central bank, together with an authority that levies taxes, that makes something count as money. This view entails that some things that appear to be money—like Bitcoin, or Somali shillings—don’t really count.

 

Personally, I think money can take many forms, so long as it serves as a shared medium that makes barter more efficient. But even setting aside the metaphysical worries I’ve raised about money, you might be vexed by ethical concerns. Putting monetary prices on things makes it easy to compare their values: the San Francisco SPCA charges $175 to adopt an adult dog, while a Nintendo Switch costs $299. But does it really make sense to say that a dog is worth less than a Nintendo Switch? Putting a price on a dog might invite inappropriate comparisons. (Such comparisons can, however, be used to great rhetorical effect: see Neil Sinhababu’s ways of reckoning the cost of the Iraq War on his blog War or Car?)

 

Perhaps some things just shouldn’t be bought and sold. I think the government should provide basic goods and services, such as roads, schools, public transit, and health care, rather than allowing these things to be traded in markets. And many people find it unsavory to sell babies, or kidneys, even though they approve of adoption and kidney donation.

 

So perhaps, contrary to popular wisdom, money is something you can have too much of after a while. I’m looking forward to puzzling over these questions with our guest, Graham Hubbs, on this week’s upcoming show, Money Matters.

 
Photo by maria pagan on Unsplash

Comments (7)


zoeyaddison's picture

zoeyaddison

Wednesday, May 15, 2024 -- 10:03 PM

Understanding personal

Understanding personal finance is essential for navigating life's financial landscape. From budgeting and saving to investing and retirement planning, mastering money management day to dusk photo editing empowers individuals to achieve their financial goals and secure their future. By cultivating financial literacy and making informed decisions, one can attain greater financial freedom and security.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
EdwardsPamela's picture

EdwardsPamela

Monday, September 16, 2024 -- 5:16 AM

Money always matters because

Money always matters because it gives you freedom of choice and opportunities for development. This is especially true in the world of cryptocurrencies, as the right investments can significantly increase capital. For example, Catizen (CTZEN) looks like an interesting option for those looking for new prospects. If you want to know more about its potential, you should check out the forecasts at https://hotcoinpost.io/catizen-price-prediction/ . Here, every investment can make a difference!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
NinaDov7's picture

NinaDov7

Saturday, October 12, 2024 -- 10:22 AM

Very important info! Thank

Very important info! Thank you for sharing

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
NinaDov7's picture

NinaDov7

Sunday, October 13, 2024 -- 1:17 PM

Money management can really

Money management can really feel like a philosophical puzzle sometimes, especially when it comes to loans and mortgages. The decisions we make about borrowing can affect our lives for years, so it's super important to choose wisely. I remember when I was looking for a mortgage, I felt overwhelmed by the options out there. To cut through the noise, I started checking out different lenders and reading reviews. That’s when I found AmeriSave reviews which provided great insights into other people's experiences. It helped me figure out if they were the right fit for me and made the whole process a lot less stressful. It’s all about finding that balance and making informed choices!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
AndrewGreen's picture

AndrewGreen

Sunday, November 24, 2024 -- 5:33 PM

Gaming online can impact your

Gaming online can impact your finances positively or negatively, depending on your approach. On the downside, in-game purchases, subscription fees, and upgrades can add up, straining your budget. Gambling games and loot boxes also carry the risk of significant financial loss. Go for for an excursion if you want to know about online casino in Greece source https://gambleorb.com/ However, online gaming can be a profitable venture when approached wisely. Streaming gameplay, participating in tournaments, or creating gaming content can generate income. To maintain balance, set a budget for gaming expenses and avoid impulsive spending. Additionally, if pursuing gaming as a source of income, invest time in honing your skills and building an audience. Remember, moderation and financial planning are essential to ensure gaming remains a fun and sustainable activity.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
CharlesFraser's picture

CharlesFraser

Tuesday, January 28, 2025 -- 11:30 AM

Your blog raises some deep

Your blog raises some deep and thought-provoking questions about the nature and ethics of money. It's fascinating how the concept of value can be so fluid, depending on context and perspective. I agree that money's essence lies in its ability to facilitate exchanges efficiently, whether it’s gold, fiat currency, or even cryptocurrency.
Speaking of evolving forms of money, for those exploring the world of crypto, a great platform for seamless transactions is LINK swap. It offers secure and efficient exchanges for digital assets!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Pabblo9's picture

Pabblo9

Wednesday, March 12, 2025 -- 9:19 AM

Neo-chartalism suggests that

Neo-chartalism suggests that money derives its value from the central bank and tax authority, shaping the financial landscape. Our Digital Credit Application Platform aligns with this modern financial framework https://www.netnow.io/products/digital-credit-application , offering a secure, customizable solution that streamlines credit applications, reduces processing time by 80%, and ensures full compliance with evolving monetary systems.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines