Philosophy of History

Sunday, December 26, 2010
First Aired: 
Sunday, January 11, 2009

What Is It

Is history just a series of events, or an interpretation of those events?  Is there progress in history?  Can history be objective, or is it, as Napoleon said, just the version of past events that people have decided to agree upon?  Ken and John delve into the past and its meaning with Daniel Little, Chancellor of the University of Michigan-Dearborn and author of History's Pathways and Varieties of Social Explanation.

Listening Notes

Ken and John kick off the show by – as happens so often – figuring out what they are talking about. Is history just a sum total of events? Or are representations of the past part of what makes the mast what it is? Is history more like literature or science?

After the philosophical reporter reports, Daniel joins Ken and John and they discuss the nature of cause in history. Are there causal laws in history? What is human causation and what is structural causation, and is there really a difference? Given that each event has many interwoven causes, how does the historian choose which causes to include in a historical study of an event?

In the next section, Daniel, Ken, and John continue to explore the balance between individual human choices, structural causes, and contingent, chance happenings. Would Hitler have been able to start World War II without structural causes and chance happenings? Ken notes that structural causes seem to constrain, but not determine, what happens.

Ken and John then wonder how much we should look for patterns in history and narrate, rather than just report brute facts in history.  Daniel points out that finding patterns in history does help us learn from the past. But how do we balance the need for narration with accuracy and comprehensiveness? Daniel defends the reputation and cause of academic history against accusations of unjust prejudice and bias.

In the last segment, Ken and John continue to discuss with Daniel the balance between getting the facts just right and pulling out inspiring, educational stories from history. Daniel emphasizes the importance of historians’ commitment to standards of rigor and commitment to evidence, and a caller argues that learning from the past means facing up to it, not sugar-coating it to find inspiration. Ken agrees, but reminds everyone of the value of the American attitude that we are not constrained to interpret ourselves as being ‘the same people’ as the people in our past who have made mistakes.

  • Roving Philosophical Report (seek to 6:00): Philosophy Talk’s roving philosophical reporter visits Presidio National Park in San Francisco, which has a new  display on the  relatively unknown war between the US and Philippines in 1900. She discovers how seemingly small remnants from the past help us uncover and understand large historical events.
  • 60-Second Philosopher (seek to 49:50): Ian Shoales reports on Giovanni Battista Vico, influential author of ‘The New Science’. Vico took an unconventionally poetic approach to history, and encouraged us to remember that historical actors are not just rational thinkers, but people with virtues and vices

Transcript

Comments (8)


Tolikam's picture

Tolikam

Sunday, September 22, 2024 -- 7:35 AM

I've been looking for a

I've been looking for a platform where I can easily design my own clothes in 3D for a long time and finally found the perfect website, https://yellowimages.com/mockups/bandana-mockup . The interface is very user-friendly, intuitive even for beginners. There is a large selection of tools for customizing fabrics, colors, and details. It is especially nice that the design can be viewed from different angles, and this gives a clear understanding of what the final product will look like. I recommend it to anyone who is interested in fashion and wants to create something unique.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Catherpillarss's picture

Catherpillarss

Wednesday, October 16, 2024 -- 8:39 AM

Bonjour, je m’appelle Sophie.

Bonjour, je m’appelle Sophie. Mon expérience sur Aurraud a été fantastique https://auraaud.casino/. L’interface est conviviale et facile à naviguer. Les jeux sont de haute qualité et j’ai adoré les promotions offertes. Les paiements sont rapides et sans tracas. Je reviendrai jouer sans hésiter.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Alexlevanda's picture

Alexlevanda

Sunday, November 17, 2024 -- 3:27 AM

Philosophy of History

Philosophy of History explains what was happening in the past to predict the present and future. But other websites, such as https://valorbettop.in/login/, allow one to participate in real-time strategy testing without having to download anything. Sometimes, catching the patterns and taking calculated risks can turn into exciting rewards!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
niboyav859's picture

niboyav859

Monday, December 9, 2024 -- 1:18 PM

Rich Casino has something for

Rich Casino has something for everyone with its huge selection of Australian entertainment. If you love slots, you will find a collection of hundreds of slot machines with different themes: adventure, fantasy, classic and more. Strategy game lovers will appreciate the variety of card and table games. And for those who want to experience a real casino, there are live games with real dealers.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
niboyav859's picture

niboyav859

Wednesday, December 18, 2024 -- 12:04 AM

With Golden Lady Casino,

With Golden Lady Casino, gambling becomes a real pleasure. Here you will find a huge selection of games, from colorful slots to exciting card and table games. The casino takes care of its customers, providing welcome bonuses and regular promotions that make the game even more interesting. A reliable security system and prompt payouts allow you to focus on the pleasure of the game. This is a place where every player feels welcome.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
gerta32's picture

gerta32

Thursday, December 26, 2024 -- 12:57 PM

What I like most about

What I like most about playing online in Canada is finding platforms that offer a little bit of everything, and that’s exactly what I’ve found with Jackpot City Casino. Their slots are diverse and fun, and I love the live casino options that bring a sense of realism to the experience. It’s a platform I’d recommend to anyone looking for quality and convenience.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
gerta32's picture

gerta32

Sunday, January 12, 2025 -- 3:51 AM

I’ve been playing at Wildz

I’ve been playing at Wildz Casino for a while now, and what I really enjoy is the smooth and modern interface. It makes navigating the site effortless, and finding my favorite games is quick and easy. In Canada, it’s hard to find a site that offers such a user-friendly experience. I can tell they really put effort into creating an intuitive platform, and it has made my gaming experience much more enjoyable.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
gerta32's picture

gerta32

Wednesday, January 15, 2025 -- 2:33 AM

The live dealer games here

The live dealer games here are exceptional. In the United Kingdom, I enjoy a good live casino experience, and Luckster Casino does not disappoint. The dealers are professional, and the streaming quality is excellent. It feels like I’m in a real casino, and I enjoy the interactive nature of the live games.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines