Tuesday, April 12, 2005
First Aired: 
Tuesday, August 24, 2004

What Is It

Rolling the dice in a game you're rigged to lose sounds like a bad idea. So why is it so much fun? Is gambling an exciting pastime, or a vicious addiction? John and Ken take their chances with Will Barrett from the University of Melbourne, author of "Luck and Decision."

Listening Notes

What is gambling? All forms of gambling involve risk taking, but is risk taking a sufficient condition for gambling? Gambling involves luck, but is luck a coherent concept? John introduces the guest, Will Barrett, research fellow at the University of Melbourne, to help answer these questions. Could a non-addicted person rationally choose to gamble? Barrett thinks she could, depending on what she expects to get out of it. John asks if buying a weekly lottery ticket is reasonable given that he doesn't think he'll win. Ken says that he is a lucky guy and he will let that belief guide his poker playing in the future. John points out that belief in luck seems similar to the gambler's fallacy. Barrett says we need to distinguish between gambling that involves some sort of skill from gambling that only involves chance. If you are able to employ skills of some kind in a game, then you can rationally engage in gambling. Games in which there is no possibility of using skills cannot be rationally played. 

What is the difference between investing and gambling that makes one rational and the other not. Barrett says that risk taking is not a sufficient condition for gambling. Investment isn't a zero-sum game, that is, there does not have to be losers if there are winners. Barrett thinks that gambling is irrational if your aim is to improve your well-being by it. A caller asks if whether this whole discussion assumes that rational action is always best. Don't we do irrational things that benefit us all the time, such as having children? 

Should the state advertise gambling? Is there a conflict between the state promoting the general welfare and the state promoting gambling? Barrett thinks so. Barrett lists several ways in which casinos try to entice gamblers into gambling more. Gambling sometimes leads to addiction and has historically been involved with organized crime. Does this mean that the state should ban gambling? Barrett thinks not since a total ban would likely lead to an increase in organized crime. But, he does not think that the state should promote gambling. Casinos hurt two groups the most: those who can least afford gambling and those who are addicted. But, states can get a lot of money from taxing gambling, so isn't gambling good?

  • Roving Philosophical Report (Seek to 4:33): Amy Standen interviews a doctor that treats patients for addictive behavior like gambling. 
  • Conundrum (Seek to 47:07): School counselors are required by law to report certain kinds of abuse, but agencies do not have the funding to follow up on most reports of abuse. In that kind of situation, what moral duties does a counselor have to the kids they are supposed to protect?


Comments (7)

cohive5679's picture


Friday, November 24, 2023 -- 8:26 AM

I recommend you hallmark

I recommend you hallmark online casino . This online casino offers you not only exciting games, but also bonuses at every turn. From big welcome bonuses to regular promotions, there's a real treat waiting for you here. Play exciting slots, enjoy the excitement of card games, and get bonuses that make your experience even more exciting.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
vorinner's picture


Monday, January 29, 2024 -- 2:17 AM

In fact, online casinos are

In fact, online casinos are safe, interesting and accessible. Perceive the game solely as a way of entertainment. The game should evoke positive emotions. This is an interesting leisure option. If you are just starting to play, choose simple and understandable games. Plan the game in advance, invite your friends. Legitimate online casinos work with the best game developers.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
hawor22689's picture


Monday, January 29, 2024 -- 2:26 AM

A great online casino

A great online casino experience is not just about security. It's also about the games on offer. This website i-casinos - goes beyond the basics, delving into the variety and quality of games available on different platforms. Whether you're a fan of slots, table games, or live dealer experiences, i-casinos guides you to casinos that provide a diverse and engaging selection of real money games.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
cohive5679's picture


Wednesday, February 7, 2024 -- 5:11 PM

Interestingly, the

Interestingly, the conversation explores different perspectives, touching on concepts such as risk, luck, skill, and the distinction between gambling and investing. Ethical considerations regarding government involvement in gambling advertising, especially given its potential negative impact on vulnerable populations . Based on this, I too want to share with you the best online casino platforms . Good luck to you

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
JamesAlvarez's picture


Monday, February 26, 2024 -- 3:41 AM

When it comes to choosing the

When it comes to choosing the best online casino, there are a few key factors I always consider. Firstly, I look for a reputable and licensed casino to ensure my safety and security. Next, I check the game selection, preferring a diverse range of slots, table games, and live dealer options. Another important aspect is the quality of bonuses and promotions offered, as they can significantly enhance the gaming experience. Recently, I came across Casino here which ticked all the boxes for me. With its user-friendly interface, extensive game library, and attractive bonuses, it's quickly become my go-to choice for online gaming. I recommend that all gamblers pay attention to it.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
dywensmith's picture


Thursday, March 28, 2024 -- 10:37 AM

Money always matters. Without

Money always matters. Without money no work is possible, be it construction, factory, or transportation. Even you can not entertain without investing money, but sometimes you get an opportunity like you do some free gaming with Slots Ventura bonus code, but I am not in favor that you joining this game without any review, first Check out some good reviewers and then make the right decision. This will help you to always be in profit.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
metira's picture


Tuesday, June 4, 2024 -- 4:23 AM

Many people are exploring

Many people are exploring online platforms to supplement their income, and tpplay download has emerged as a popular choice among them. Offering a range of earning opportunities, from completing surveys to engaging in online activities, it provides users with flexible ways to make money. The platform's straightforward interface and prompt payouts have contributed to its positive reputation. Consider visiting this to discover its earning potential.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines