Different Cultures, Different Selves

Sunday, January 23, 2011
First Aired: 
Sunday, February 22, 2009

What Is It

Why do we do what we do? To please others? To live up to what culture expects? Or for our own reasons –- as "autonomous agents"? Americans tend to admire (at least in theory) the autonomous individual, the person who knows what he wants, and sets out to get it, no matter what the world might think. Is this true of all cultures? John and Ken are joined by Stanford Psychologist Hazel Markus to explore differences in motivation and action across cultures.

Listening Notes

 

“Know thyself.” “To thine own self be true.” “You can go your own way.” From the ancient Greeks to Shakespeare to Fleetwood Mac, there’s a long tradition in Western civilization of seeing each person as separate from every other. Often times this goes hand in hand with the permission, or even imperative, to ignore others’ expectations and “follow your heart.” Raised in this culture, this seems like a perfectly natural view of selfhood. But what if there were other ways of thinking about the self?

Our show begins with John disputing the idea that people in different cultures have fundamentally different notions of the self: After all, we all believe that we possess the power of rational thought, bodies we control, and senses we use to explore the environment around us, don’t we?

Hazel Markus, professor in Behavioral Sciences at Stanford University, offers a response based on evidence she’s gleaned from studying Japanese society. According to Markus, Japanese culture holds a fundamentally different notion of the self from mainstream American culture, which views the self as completely autonomous. From the Japanese point of view, the most important information about a person is all the relationships he or she is born into, extending back many generations. Markus offers empirical evidence to show that this view of the self affects how children behave.

In the final section, we consider what the effects might be of realizing that there are multiple conceptions of the self. Can we choose to adopt another culture’s concept or is our own just too far ingrained in our minds? Ken pushes Hazel on the question of cultural relativism. Doesn’t the Western concept of the autonomous self have important benefits, like valuing individual freedoms? Hazel agrees but pushes back, encouraging Ken to question his view of others’ expectations as onerous burdens. The show ends with a few thoughts on how we might offer children a choice among different ideas of the self.    

  • Roving Philosophical Report: Nancy Mullane examines the link between an autonomous notion of the self and altruistic behavior.  She talks to Dacher Keltner, professor of psychology at Berkeley, about how evolution has given us brains that reward altruistic behavior, and about how we should value compassion more in our culture.  
  • 60-Second philosopher: Ian Shoales reveals that Americans are the most self-conscious people on earth. Consider our inventions: self-help books, motivational speakers, fitness centers. And think about the terms of our therapy: personal growth (good), co-dependence (bad). Is self-obsession really the only way to go?

Transcript

Comments (5)


Tolikam's picture

Tolikam

Wednesday, November 13, 2024 -- 1:41 PM

Software solutions from white

Software solutions from white label casino change the rules of the game. They create an interface where every detail is carefully thought out for the maximum comfort of users. The developers have invested everything that a modern casino needs in the product: from performance to reliable security. Thanks to this, we can focus on the marketing and development of the platform, leaving all technical aspects here. We are happy to cooperate with those who understand the needs of the industry to the fullest.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
coral's picture

coral

Saturday, November 16, 2024 -- 1:26 PM

If you want to play well

If you want to play well online in Australia, then you definitely need to try here - PrimaPlay if you are interested in playing offline, you should definitely try to play here because it is an incredible game in order to spend time well, for example, after work I prefer to play only utt it is my hobby!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
kalibri's picture

kalibri

Sunday, November 17, 2024 -- 6:46 AM

It has been a real find for

It has been a real find for me https://luckystar-india.com/ . Now we save all our data in our phones and computers and we all have a question how not to become victims of fraudsters. This platform is responsible to protect the data and privacy of its users. Together with them you can definitely forget about the danger and threats because everything is done perfectly.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Alexsx's picture

Alexsx

Saturday, November 30, 2024 -- 2:23 PM

I saw https://uk

I saw https://uk.nongamstopcasinos.net/slots/book-of-dead-not-on-gamstop/ mentioned in a forum, and the hype was real. The classic Egyptian theme and rewarding features make it a favorite for many UK players. It’s easy to see why it’s so popular—there’s always something exciting happening on the reels. If you’re into Egyptian mythology, try Book of Dead (not on GamStop).

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
gerta32's picture

gerta32

Friday, January 17, 2025 -- 10:17 AM

I really appreciate the

I really appreciate the quality of the games available here. The graphics, sound effects, and overall design are top-notch. El Royale Casino offers a truly immersive experience that keeps me hooked for hours. It’s refreshing to see a site in Australia that puts so much effort into creating high-quality games that look and feel amazing.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines