Can the Laws of Physics Change?
Aug 12, 2017What if gravity suddenly stopped working? Or what if e=mc3 rather than e=mc2? Could the fundamentals of physics really change?
From airplanes flying overhead to the cellular activity inside us, all events that take place in the world obey the laws of physics. Physicists seem to be getting closer and closer to understanding the physical laws that govern our universe. But what if our physical laws changed? Could that even be possible? How might changing of physical laws affect us? Or is just that what we take to be laws changes over time? Should we still call the laws of physics “laws”? The philosophers conserve mass with Massimo Pigliucci from the City University of New York, author of Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk.
Part of our series A Philosophical Guide to the Cosmos.
Ken wonders if the idea of the laws of physics changing even makes sense, to which guest host Jenann Ismael, visiting from the University of Arizona, answers that the evolution of physical laws could be possible. She proposes that a kind of “cosmic selection” could have selected for the fine-tuned universe that we have today. That is, after different trial runs, the physical laws that could not sustain cosmology died out, while the ones that could survived. But Ken is still skeptical that the laws of physics are mutable, reminding us that we inherited the concept of “fundamental physical laws” from Newton. Even the idea that the laws of physics abide by a law of evolution seems paradoxical to Ken.
The philosophers welcome Massimo Pigliucci, professor of philosophy at the City University of New York, to a second run on the show. Massimo argues that the word “law” (in the context of a “law of physics” or “law of nature”) is problematic. He maintains that the concept of a law raises the question of who or what decided the law to be that way. Massimo also notes that although Newton insisted that physicists should think in terms of immutable laws of nature, this idea was controversial in his day. Newton’s contemporaries, including Galileo, believed that scientists should avoid rhetoric about physical laws since they believed that scientific observations are only local and empirical. From this the philosophers agree that, unlike other fields like biology or sociology, physics insists fundamental laws to perhaps its detriment.
After a few callers and a short break, Ken asks Massimo what consequences would follow if physicists confirmed that the laws of physics change. Massimo responds that evidence for changing physics would force physicists to consider how different causal interactions and parameters in physics create novel effects more in depth. He adds that the philosophy of physics is now increasingly turning to biology in order to understand phenomena of this kind.
Comments (25)
Harold G. Neuman
Wednesday, August 9, 2017 -- 3:17 PM
Physics laws (?)The question was: could the laws of physics ever change? Yes, they could. We just don't know how. Yet.
shaka
Wednesday, March 27, 2024 -- 3:04 AM
Seamless Streaming, EndlessSeamless Streaming, Endless Possibilities:[url=https://vidmatemodapk.com/]Vidmate 2024 apk [/url]
Harold G. Neuman
Sunday, December 1, 2019 -- 10:52 AM
On a comment about aOn a comment about a different post, one reader made a reference to time travel, appearing to say that it is inevitable. I don't know if anyone has said this before, and since I am pedestrian when it comes to physics, I have no way of knowing if it could be true. Does anyone know? Thanks,
Neuman
Tim Smith
Wednesday, December 11, 2019 -- 9:36 AM
This is the droid you lookingThis is the droid you are looking for ...
https://www.ttbook.org/show/time-travel
This is perhaps more on topic of the show and blog...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Hi4VbERDyI
Lee Smolin is smart if not respected. He is referenced in the show.
Time travel is real, relative and tricky as heck to think about. You can travel back in cosmological time by looking at the sky at night unfortunately in fewer and fewer environs. You could do the same by looking at your analog TV screen between the channels. That too is being removed with digital broadcasts (another form of light pollution or is there a conspiracy a foot to completly detach humans from the real world?)
If that seems like cheating then what is perception? The sun could blow and we wouldn't know it until 8 minutes later. The mirror is a similar way of looking at your past self.
Certainly time is relative, it travels at different rates. In a similar vain nothing goes faster than the speed of light yet muons traverse certain media faster than light... that is cherenkov radiation.
Physics confounds me. I hope someone actually answers your question ... but I tell you everything I have written above is likely true and the majority of Physicists would agree ... except for the part about Lee Smolin being smart.
Harold... complete threadjack here but... you were exactly right about Bentham BTW... I put an inter library loan request in and it was not honored. I was able to get some of his writing over the dark web. That evidently is real even if dark matter and energy can't be detected through millions of public science dollars.
Best to you. We are at least traveling in the same time if at different rates, it seems to be speeding up in my reference frame. That speeding up however is the only law I'm certain of at the moment.
Tim Smith
Wednesday, December 11, 2019 -- 9:35 AM
Cross posting this with theCross posting this with the blog... I liked this show but it made me feel not so confident I know anything.
This is my blog post...
Physics has so so much to do.
Newton was falsely taken in by his times and internecine academic rivalry to rise above his inherent bias toward the fundamentality of creation. He saw it as part and parcel of his world view. I would have to read his work much more in depth to say whether the previous sentence is right or not. Now that I have said it... I think back and I do recall several passages where Newton seems to break and speak directly to the reader, like Galen, that the reader or future generations must decide and look.
Regardless of Newton's own view, his very astute insight has caused us all to believe we understand the heavens and that laws here are laws there... and by this profundity... laws exist. They don't. Einstein has done worse. He has defied reason, used his own profundity to question entanglement... and by this denial... created a bit of a cult. Science persists with or without cults but is the worse for indulging them. This is evidenced in wasted effort and denial of plausible alternative hypotheses. It is a sham that Darpa is often the forward thinking fund source over our own public science. But ... I digress.
Causality is fine to presume. I prefer turtles all the way down. Physics has it's own emergent paradigms that defy causal reasoning... I think.
Why are there 12 fermions and only 3 required to make everything we know? What do the other nine do? What is dark matter or dark energy and why can't we detect it like Newton detected gravity? Why is dark matter only interactive gravitationally on cosmic scales? Why is gravity so weak and why no graviton? Why can we only touch 5% of matter? The list goes on and on... Physics is a mess. Don't get me started on funding. There is a phoneme that leads to a Lewis Carrollian rabbit hole. Again I digress... but it is all about the benjamins.
Yet Physics is pointed to as a fundamental science. It is not. It is only a science. A very important science but not the most important one. Certainly it is no indicator of immutable laws, which is what Newton unfortunately promulgated.
I have a very difficult time seeing how we could detect laws changing on cosmic or even personal scales when time and perception are tied to activity and proximity in the brain. Remove the fusiform gyrus and we can't recognize faces yet we still understand the concept of face and even see it?? I'm not sure generational perceptions are preserved in my own lifetime. The laws of physics could alter over millenia and this just may not compute. We haven't done that either much less explained the super voids of the cosmos.
Particles hit the earth, millions of them, at velocities that defy explanation. There are laws to be re-written. Bring on the turtles. Science is all about the turtles ... all the way down.
This is kind of cool. You can download an app to help detect these cosmic rays... https://crayfis.io/about
I don't know what made me add on that last plug... I'm not sure there is causality. But I too am not betting my pension on that.
margaretshmit
Tuesday, February 27, 2024 -- 9:24 AM
In the fast-paced world ofIn the fast-paced world of academia, students often find themselves overwhelmed by the sheer volume of assignments, essays, and projects they need to complete. Balancing coursework with other responsibilities can be a daunting task, leaving many students feeling stressed and exhausted. However, in this digital age, a solution has emerged to alleviate some of the burdens of academic workload: essay writing services.
Essay writing services https://paperwriter.com/write-my-discussion-board-post have become increasingly popular among students seeking assistance with their assignments. These services offer a range of benefits that can help students unlock their academic potential and achieve success in their studies.
ChristinaTorres
Sunday, March 17, 2024 -- 1:42 PM
I found Emily Chacon'sI found Emily Chacon's detailed review of PapersOwl.com on https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/detailed-papersowlcom-review-emily-chacon-v6mjf/ insightful. It's essential for students seeking essay help to explore comprehensive reviews like this. Understanding the experiences of others can guide decision-making and ensure quality service. Chacon's analysis sheds light on various aspects, aiding potential users in making informed choices. Such reviews foster transparency and accountability in the academic assistance industry, benefiting students immensely.
kimmorgan
Tuesday, March 19, 2024 -- 3:01 AM
In contemplating whether theIn contemplating whether the laws of physics could ever change, one enters the realm of profound philosophical inquiry intertwined with scientific curiosity. At https://writepaper.com/write-my-philosophy-paper, this topic prompts a fascinating exploration of the nature of reality and our understanding of it. The laws of physics, as we currently comprehend them, serve as fundamental principles governing the behavior of matter and energy in the universe. Yet, the very nature of scientific inquiry leaves room for the possibility of these laws evolving or being refined over time as our understanding deepens. While such a prospect may seem radical, history has shown that our comprehension of the physical world is dynamic and subject to revision. Whether through revolutionary paradigm shifts or incremental adjustments, the evolution of scientific theories underscores the humility with which we approach the mysteries of the cosmos. Thus, while the laws of physics appear immutable within the scope of our current knowledge, the prospect of their transformation remains a tantalizing prospect for future generations of scientists and philosophers to explore.
alexseen
Monday, April 29, 2024 -- 6:37 AM
As we were expanding ourAs we were expanding our startup, we found it difficult to effectively engage B2B clients through LinkedIn because we didn't have enough resources to do so. So we decided to look for a tool that would help us optimize this process. Now we use Generating leads on LinkedIn effectively https://octopuscrm.io/linkedin-lead-generation-software/ remains a pivotal focus for any B2B organization looking for consistent and dependable revenue streams. Utilize the Octopus CRM LinkedIn lead generation tool for your business in 2024. This tool has provided us with integration with our CRM system and automation of our contact sequences, allowing us to reach more leads. Now our team can focus on quality instead of quantity, which is a great advantage for us.
boystrong1002
Thursday, August 29, 2024 -- 8:06 PM
Great article spanishGreat article spanish dictionary, it is really helpful! I just started and I am getting the hang of it! Thanks, keep up the good work! temple run 3
seniorloki
Thursday, October 24, 2024 -- 1:47 AM
The idea of whether the lawsThe idea of whether the laws of physics could ever change is fascinating, especially when thinking about games like Fire Kirin casino from https://fire-kirinapk.com. In the game, everything operates under its own set of rules and mechanics, much like how our world is governed by physics. If those rules were to suddenly shift, it would completely change how we play and experience the game, adding unexpected challenges or opportunities.
seniorloki
Thursday, October 24, 2024 -- 1:48 AM
In real life, the laws ofIn real life, the laws of physics shape everything around us, but imagining them differently—like in Toca Life premium app—opens up endless possibilities for fun and creativity. It’s a cool way to think about how different the world could be!
firekirinapp
Monday, November 18, 2024 -- 9:49 PM
Currently, the FireKirin appCurrently, the FireKirin app is primarily designed for Android devices https://firekirinapp.pro/. For iOS, alternative solutions may be required.
wuhan
Saturday, November 30, 2024 -- 6:13 AM
Fascinating topic on theFascinating topic on the potential for laws of physics to change! It's mind-boggling to think about how fundamental laws could evolve over time. While contemplating such profound ideas, you might enjoy a fun and engaging break by checking out firekirin web . It’s an action-packed game with a mix of strategy and excitement—perfect for when you need a mental reset!
henryjimy
Monday, December 2, 2024 -- 8:49 AM
Fascinating discussion on theFascinating discussion on the possibility of changes in the laws of physics! It really makes you think about how our understanding of the universe could evolve. On a lighter note, if you enjoy exploring new experiences, you might want to check out Fire Kirin. It's an exciting game you can download and play on your Android device. To get started, download fire kirin apk for android
kainat
Wednesday, December 4, 2024 -- 9:50 AM
Interesting perspective onInteresting perspective on the laws of physics! It makes me wonder, just like in Shadow Fight 2 MOD APK
, where breaking the usual rules adds a twist to the gameplay. What if changing the rules in real life could open new possibilities too?
kainat
Saturday, December 7, 2024 -- 9:26 AM
"Interesting thoughts on the"Interesting thoughts on the laws of physics! Just like in the Avatar world MOD APK, where the rules can change and create entirely new experiences, it makes you wonder how different our reality could be if the physical laws were flexible. What do you think?"
saimy09
Wednesday, December 11, 2024 -- 6:46 AM
The idea of whether the lawsThe idea of whether the laws of physics could ever change is fascinating. Just as scientific principles are fundamental to understanding the universe, having the best tools at your disposal is key in any field. For example, if you’re looking for the best Android app for your phone , Panda Master offers an engaging and enjoyable experience for gaming enthusiasts.
JoinersStirling
Thursday, December 26, 2024 -- 1:01 AM
Joiners near me Stirling,Joiners near me Stirling, joinery is not just a trade; it is a way of life—a reflection of the town's rich cultural heritage and a testament to the enduring power of craftsmanship. Through their work, the joiners of Dunblane pay homage to those who came before them, preserving centuries-old techniques for future generations to enjoy. In doing so, they ensure that the tradition of woodworking remains alive and vibrant in a rapidly changing world.
As the sun sets over the rolling hills of central Scotland, the workshops of Dunblane's joiners fall silent, their work for the day complete. Yet, their legacy endures—a testament to the timeless allure of craftsmanship and the profound impact it can have on both individuals and communities alike. In Dunblane, the tradition of joinery lives on, a beacon of inspiration and a reminder of the enduring value of handmade excellence.
JoinersStirling
Friday, January 3, 2025 -- 10:40 AM
The Falkirk & CentralThe Falkirk & Central Scotland Business Directory organizes local enterprises into categories for easy navigation and community connection. Popular categories include Retail, featuring shops and stores; Hospitality, highlighting restaurants, cafes, and accommodations; and Trades & Services, covering plumbers, electricians, and other skilled professionals. Other key areas are Health & Wellness, showcasing gyms, clinics, and therapists, and Professional Services, which includes accountants, lawyers, and consultants. Additionally, categories like Arts & Entertainment and Education & Training foster creativity and learning. This structure ensures users quickly find relevant businesses, supporting local commerce and fostering economic growth across the Falkirk and Central Scotland region.
https://falkirkmusicscene.co.uk/
JoinersStirling
Friday, January 3, 2025 -- 10:41 AM
Composite Decking, TimberComposite Decking, Timber Decking, and Glass Balustrade Fitters in Stirling
Homeowners in Stirling seeking to enhance their outdoor spaces often consider composite decking, timber decking, and glass balustrades for both functionality and style. These features not only elevate the aesthetic appeal of gardens and terraces but also improve usability and safety.
Composite decking offers a low-maintenance, durable solution that resists weathering and fading. Made from recycled materials, it’s eco-friendly and ideal for busy households seeking long-lasting performance without frequent upkeep. This decking option provides a contemporary look, perfect for modern homes in Stirling.
Timber decking, on the other hand, adds a natural, rustic charm to outdoor areas. It blends seamlessly with the surrounding environment and can be treated to withstand the unpredictable Scottish weather. Skilled fitters in the Stirling area can customize timber decking to suit various property styles and sizes.
Glass balustrades complement decking projects, providing sleek safety solutions without obstructing views. They are particularly popular for elevated decking areas, offering a minimalist and sophisticated design.
https://armodecking.com/
ameliamax
Saturday, January 11, 2025 -- 6:01 AM
The idea of the laws ofThe idea of the laws of physics changing is both fascinating and mind-boggling. It really makes you think about the fundamental nature of our universe and how much we have yet to understand. On a different note, if you’re looking for something engaging and fun, check out this link: https://vblink.app/how-to-play-vblink777/. It offers a comprehensive guide on how to enjoy and excel at playing Vblink777!
xavimax
Saturday, January 11, 2025 -- 7:59 AM
The discussion on theThe discussion on the potential for the laws of physics to change is truly mind-expanding! It's always intriguing to think about how science might evolve. On a different note, if you're looking for a fun and interactive game, you can check out https://fire-kirin.pro/how-to-download-fire-kirin-on-ios/ for a step-by-step guide to download the Fire Kirin game on your iOS device.
kimyoun34
Monday, January 13, 2025 -- 6:59 PM
Worms Zone for PC brings theWorms Zone for PC brings the fun of the classic arcade game to a bigger screen. Enjoy smooth controls, vibrant graphics, and competitive gameplay as you grow your worm, collect food, and dominate the leaderboard. Perfect for players who love strategic challenges! https://wormzoneapk.com/worms-zone-for-pc/
firekirnmodapk
Wednesday, January 22, 2025 -- 10:09 PM
Fire Kirin APKFire Kirin APK
has become one of the famous apps owing to its ability to give users the opportunity to play online games as well as earn. The credit for this service goes to XGaming.
https://fire-kirinapk.org/