Immigration and Multiculturalism
Mar 10, 2019Whether for economic reasons or to flee violence and persecution, immigration rates continue to climb globally.
In response to our recent show "Immigration and Multiculturalism" with guest Prof. Sarah Song, listener Judy asked:
First, I would like to have known what was meant by Dr. Song's comment that immigrants are obligated to integrate. What does integration mean, and how is that contrasted to assimilation?
Second, I heard her say that immigrants' opinions have nothing to do with culture. What?? Did I hear wrong? If not, I don't get it because such opinions have everything to do with culture.
Now, she said that something to the effect that immigrants deserve full participation in America, and that this entails the right to change the culture. This is precisely where things become fraught. Again, what is "integration"? How much integration do we have a right to expect? What kinds of changes become intolerable?
I struggle with this question, and I'm wondering how other people see it?
Sarah was kind enough to write a response:
I distinguish assimilation from integration. Assimilation is associated with the ideal of the melting pot in which immigrants are expected to give up their distinctive collective identities and cultural practices in favor of adopting the identities and practices associated with the dominant culture. By contrast, integration is an ideal that asks immigrants to adopt the basic values and principles of the societies they've migrated to (such as the values of equality and respect for the rule of law), but immigrants can maintain their distinctive cultural identities and practices. This ideal of integration is compatible with a range of multiculturalism policies; indeed, policies that seek to accommodate the cultural practices of immigrants provide fairer terms of integration for immigrants.
You are right that the question of how much integration is a fraught one. If immigrants hold beliefs and engage in practices that contravene liberal democratic norms, such as gender equality, then you're faced with a conflict between respecting cultural differences and upholding important norms. There is no general or easy answer to such conflicts; much will depend on context. I write more about such conflicts in my Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy essay on multiculturalism.
Thanks, Sarah!
If you have a question or comment that did not get addressed during the show, feel free to leave a comment on the website or send us an email at comments@philosophytalk.org and we might just feature it here on the blog!
Comments (32)
Tim Smith
Monday, April 1, 2019 -- 9:18 PM
Here we go...Judy said.Here we go...Judy said.
|Now, she said that something to the effect that immigrants deserve full participation in America, and that this entails the right to change the |culture. This is precisely where things become fraught. Again, what is "integration"? How much integration do we have a right to expect? What |kinds of changes become intolerable?
I don't think it's a matter of deserving full participation, integration or righteous expectations. Integration is being free without the right to harm others - especially vulnerable co-residents. If taxes are paid... I'm good with immigrants trying to change our culture. No one controls culture for long.
meganf
Wednesday, April 3, 2019 -- 12:57 AM
Tim is making a good point.Tim is making a good point. Culture is not a constant. Sometimes, people like to regard it as "consistent" by saying that society prefers certain "values," but even values are just social claims that serve a prescriptive forward-looking function or serve as means of characterizing retrospective judgments on past social behavior. I would argue that the social values of our country have changed throughout the years as public opinion has changed.
I had Sarah as a professor last fall for a class in which she touched briefly upon immigration and membership. I remember one point made was that if we apply an approach like John Rawls' "original position" to a broader global view that embodies immigration, the effect of immigration on a country's culture should not be a relevant moral consideration unless there's a real threat to liberal democratic values. I am not sure that there are any fundamental cultural aspects embedded in a sovereign state except for the fundamental social contract between its citizens and the state in the constitution. From this perspective, it would seem that integration is acceptable as long as the new immigrants abide by the conditions of the social contract.
Places of birth and the citizenship that it confers are arbitrary to the individual. A citizen's claim that they have any superior entitlement right to exclude immigrants seems relatively unfounded to me personally. It's also noteworthy to keep in mind that the United States had a relatively open immigration policy until the 1920s (with the exception of the Chinese Exclusion Act), which marked the emergence of the use of passports and the Immigration Act of 1924 that limited the inflow of immigrants.
Pressuring new immigrants to culturally assimilate evokes senses of cultural superiority, nearing senses of moral superiority that are relatively arbitrary. Cultural assimilation serves as erasure by communicating which cultures are more socially acceptable, whereas integration acknowledges each individual's right to autonomy without fallaciously pitting individual's (cultural) identities as "foreign" and against the state. Instead, a less xenophobic approach would be attempting to address these social conflicts from the context that these individuals are already part of the state. The argument that certain immigrants import "backwards" or morally depraved cultures is generalized and assumes that immigrants cannot or are not willing to abide by the terms of the social contract of a country which they are choosing to immigrate to, the act of which, by all means indicates that they demonstrate their acknowledgment of their intention to be just as legally bound to these rules as any other citizen in the country's jurisdiction. But, this point also brings up the question that if what we are really looking for is a community of not humans, who are fallible by nature and not by race, but a community of morally acceptable citizens, how is it that we choose not to deport natural born citizens who are just as much arbitrarily pre-dispositioned to be morally fallible? Our country unfairly endows additional rights and protections upon individuals born here than those who were not. I think this shows some of the conflicts we face when culture is seen as in conflict or inhibitive to civic participation.
Harold G. Neuman
Monday, January 31, 2022 -- 5:51 AM
This is pretty far after-theThis is pretty far after-the-fact. I too was uncertain about the usage of integration. That term is charged from the get-go. Assimilation is a softer way of talking about people fitting in. Dr. Song's points are well-taken by myself (and probably others). But, her explanation, I am certain, missed the mark for sensitive folks who have seen negative outcome, no matter which term is applied. Whether we are talking about swords ( double-edged):; razors (thin and sharp): or brooms ( tending to miss important minutiae), things get missed, if not lost, in translation. Some people, otherwise fit and willing to do so, have no wish to either assimilate or integrate. They simply desire the freedoms for which a free society claims to stand; the opportunities unavailable elsewhere.
wintercurrants
Thursday, November 23, 2023 -- 1:07 AM
The claim that someThe claim that some immigrants bring "backwards" or morally reprehensible cultures is overly broad and presupposes that immigrants are unable or unwilling to live up to the social compact of the nation they have chosen to immigrate to basket random. This is because their choice to immigrate by itself by no means indicates that they do not acknowledge that they will be subject to the same laws and regulations as any other citizen of the nation.
sarausa
Tuesday, December 19, 2023 -- 5:24 PM
In my opinion, we shouldIn my opinion, we should harmonize mapquest directions and not assimilate because when we assimilate, it will be very difficult to preserve each nation's own culture.
ellalarsen
Monday, January 15, 2024 -- 4:11 AM
Engaging read on theEngaging read on the intricate debate between integration and assimilation. The nuances of this topic are as complex and thought-provoking as an real iq test. It's fascinating to delve into the philosophical aspects of cultural identity and societal norms. Great piece that stimulates deep reflection!
orlandoolivia106
Sunday, February 25, 2024 -- 10:09 PM
Hello! I'm Olivia Orlando, aHello! I'm Olivia Orlando, a passionate web designer dedicated to crafting visually stunning and user-friendly websites. With a keen eye for detail and a commitment to excellence, I specialize in creating bespoke digital experiences that captivate audiences and drive results. Whether you're a small business owner looking to establish a strong online presence or a creative professional seeking to showcase your work, I'm here to bring your vision to life. Let's collaborate to design a website that reflects your unique personality and achieves your goals. Get in touch today to start your digital journey Flair Airlines Teléfono México
orlandoolivia106
Monday, May 27, 2024 -- 10:35 PM
¿Cómo llamar a Delta en¿Cómo llamar a Delta en México?
¿Cómo llamar a Delta en México?
¿Cómo llamar a Delta en México?
¿Cómo llamar a Delta en México?
change flight
goodstudent66
Wednesday, June 19, 2024 -- 7:59 PM
I'm so glad I found this toolI'm so glad I found this tool. It's been a lifesaver final grade calculator
cheokwaiun
Tuesday, August 27, 2024 -- 11:37 AM
Writinkservices.comWritinkservices.com specializes in providing expert assistance for nursing students. If you're struggling with complex assignments, you can rely on their professional team to write my nursing paper for me with precision and care. They understand the specific requirements and challenges of nursing papers, ensuring that your work is thoroughly researched and accurately formatted. With Writink Services, you can confidently submit high-quality nursing papers that meet academic standards and help you succeed in your studies.
leooscar
Wednesday, September 18, 2024 -- 12:15 AM
As education shifts towardsAs education shifts towards digital platforms, nursing paper writers online class learning management systems (LMS) have become crucial tools for students and educators alike. These systems streamline the educational experience, enabling students to access coursework, track progress, and engage with peers and instructors in a virtual environment. For students pursuing demanding fields like nursing, LMS platforms provide invaluable support.
Nursing students, in particular, benefit from online learning systems as they balance rigorous coursework with clinical practice. The ability to manage time, review materials, and participate in discussions is critical to their success. Many nursing students seek extra help, such as hiring nursing paper writers for assistance with complex assignments. These writers specialize in providing quality papers that meet academic standards, allowing students to focus on mastering the practical elements of their studies.
For those who need help with school online, LMS platforms offer flexible options, from virtual classrooms to interactive assignments. They accommodate diverse learning styles and schedules, making it easier for students to stay on top of their work. Whether seeking tutoring, assignment help, or nursing paper writing services, these systems support the academic journey, ensuring students can achieve their educational goals efficiently.
In conclusion, online class learning management systems are vital in today’s education landscape, help with school online especially for nursing students. They offer accessible, organized, and flexible solutions, helping students navigate their online education while balancing their responsibilities.
leooscar
Wednesday, September 18, 2024 -- 12:18 AM
In the fast-paced world ofIn the fast-paced world of online education, many students, nursing paper help particularly those pursuing demanding degrees like nursing, often seek extra support to succeed. Balancing coursework, clinical hours, and personal responsibilities can be overwhelming. This is where student support networks and specialized services, such as nursing paper help and options to seek assistance with online classes, come into play.
One common question asked by students is, The increasing availability of online tutoring and assignment assistance services has made this option more accessible. For students feeling swamped by their workload, especially when writing assignments like nursing papers, such services offer targeted help. Nursing paper help services specifically provide expert guidance on research, formatting, and content development, ensuring students meet academic standards.
These networks and services are not just about easing the workload—they help students manage time more effectively, stay on track with their studies, and achieve better academic outcomes. By leveraging these resources, nursing students can focus on their clinical training while still succeeding in their coursework, balancing the complex demands of modern education.
In summary, online class student support networks, can i pay someone to take my online class including nursing paper help and tutoring services, provide essential assistance, enabling students to excel in their academic journey without feeling overwhelmed.
coursefpx
Wednesday, September 18, 2024 -- 9:06 AM
Great question! When it comesGreat question! When it comes to platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube, the decision to integrate or assimilate depends on your goals. Integration means keeping each platform’s unique identity while working together, allowing you to reach different audiences. Assimilation involves blending content and strategies across platforms for consistency. At COURSEFPX , we encourage a tailored approach — understanding your audience and purpose is key to determining which strategy will help you achieve your objectives most effectively.
harry9
Wednesday, September 18, 2024 -- 11:44 PM
Do you find your businessseanferis
Wednesday, November 20, 2024 -- 3:49 AM
Cultural diversity inCultural diversity in university group assignments brings both challenges and opportunities for students and instructors alike. As universities become more globalized, classrooms increasingly consist of students from diverse cultural backgrounds. This diversity can lead to a broader range of perspectives, experiences, and skills being brought to group assignments. In an ideal setting, these differences could enhance the depth of the project, as team members may approach the assignment from unique angles based on their cultural understandings. However, without proper guidance, this diversity can also create take my online class misunderstandings and conflicts within the group, especially if cultural differences are not acknowledged or respected.
One of the main benefits of cultural diversity in group assignments is the opportunity for students to learn from one another’s diverse perspectives. For example, students from different countries may bring varied methodologies, problem-solving techniques, and insights that can enrich the overall quality of the work. A diverse group is more likely to think critically and creatively, considering a wider range of ideas and solutions. This collaborative learning environment can also help students develop cultural competence, an essential skill in today’s interconnected world.
seanferis
Wednesday, November 20, 2024 -- 3:55 AM
Accreditation plays a crucialAccreditation plays a crucial role in ensuring the quality and legitimacy of online education. It serves as a seal of approval granted by recognized accreditation bodies, confirming that an online institution or program meets specific educational standards. Without proper accreditation, online courses and programs risk being perceived as substandard or less credible. This is especially significant in today’s competitive job market, where employers often require degrees or certifications from accredited institutions to validate a candidate's qualifications. Accreditation helps maintain a level of trust in do My Course online learning, allowing students to confidently pursue their education with the knowledge that they are receiving quality instruction.
One of the primary functions of accreditation is to safeguard the educational experience of students. Accrediting organizations set rigorous standards to ensure that the curriculum, teaching methods, and faculty qualifications meet the expectations of higher education. For example, accrediting bodies assess whether an institution provides adequate resources, such as access to libraries, technology, and support services. These standards help ensure that online students have access to the same educational opportunities as those attending traditional in-person institutions. This is crucial in a field like online education, where students may be learning remotely without direct access to campus resources.
martindew
Thursday, November 28, 2024 -- 2:21 AM
Taking everything intoTaking everything into account, african print addresses something other than apparel; it is a festival of culture, personality, and imagination. From the energetic prints of West Africa to the many-sided beadwork of East Africa,African dresses UK epitomizes the soul and strength of the mainland's assorted people groups. As the world proceeds to embrace and observe African style, ladies' African wear will stay an immortal image of African legacy and pride, associating ladies across boundaries and ages in a common festival of culture and personality.
martindew
Thursday, November 28, 2024 -- 2:22 AM
The african dresses ,The african dresses , frequently hailed as an image of social pride and stylish articulation, has spellbound design lovers overall with its energetic tones, complicated examples, and rich social legacy. Established in exceptionally old African material practices, the African print dress stands as a demonstration of the mainland's different societies, customs, and imagination. In this article, we dive into the set of experiences, importance, and persevering through allure of the African print dress, investigating its excursion from conventional attire to worldwide design symbol.
martindew
Thursday, November 28, 2024 -- 2:24 AM
Moreover, solidworksMoreover, solidworks training also addresses industry-specific needs. For example, a designer in the automotive sector may focus on simulation tools and motion studies, while a designer in the consumer electronics field may focus on optimizing designs for injection molding. Training allows professionals to gain specialized knowledge that not only enhances their efficiency but also ensures that their designs meet the technical and regulatory requirements of their specific industry.
martindew
Thursday, November 28, 2024 -- 2:25 AM
Ultimately, solidworksUltimately, solidworks training that is customized to fit specific workflow needs empowers professionals to maximize the software’s potential. Whether working in a niche area or managing complex, large-scale designs, this training ensures that users can optimize their design processes and achieve exceptional results more efficiently.
james44
Friday, December 6, 2024 -- 9:37 AM
I am here to provide KinoGo,I am here to provide KinoGo, a popular streaming platform offering a wide range of TV series and movies across various genres. The site features both international and Russian content, often available in high definition. Users can stream the latest episodes and enjoy free access to a vast collection of shows. KinoGo is designed for ease of use, with options like subtitles and video quality adjustments to enhance the viewing experience. Follow the above link to visit the services page.
jimmiplus
Wednesday, December 11, 2024 -- 4:04 AM
Welcome to Parent Living PlusWelcome to Parent Living Plus ! We are a group of travel lovers who enjoy discovering locations and uncovering top-notch accommodations in the United States and abroad. Our goal is straightforward.
jimmiplus
Wednesday, December 11, 2024 -- 4:09 AM
Grants for Nonprofits, SmallGrants for Nonprofits, Small Business, Individuals Catalog. 36100 Grants. 128179 Grant Providers. Sign up for free grant alerts from grant providers!
jimmiplus
Wednesday, December 11, 2024 -- 4:11 AM
Welcome to best hotels inWelcome to best hotels in belize! We are a group of travel lovers who enjoy discovering locations and uncovering top-notch accommodations in the United States and abroad. Our goal is straightforward.
tawave1622
Friday, December 27, 2024 -- 12:03 AM
When it comes to finding theWhen it comes to finding the best car rental in Dubai, Lavish Cars sets the standard with its exceptional service and diverse fleet. From compact cars for quick trips to luxurious vehicles for special occasions, they have options that suit every requirement. Their seamless booking process, competitive rates, and dedication to customer satisfaction make them a trusted choice. Experience the convenience and style of driving in Dubai with Lavish Cars, your partner for premium car rentals.
tawave1622
Friday, December 27, 2024 -- 12:06 AM
For top-tier car rentalFor top-tier car rental services in Dubai, Lavish Cars offers a perfect blend of quality, variety, and convenience. Their extensive fleet includes everything from economy cars to high-end luxury vehicles, ensuring there’s something for every traveler. Whether you’re in Dubai for a quick business trip or a leisurely vacation, their flexible rental plans and competitive pricing make transportation hassle-free. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Lavish Cars ensures a seamless and enjoyable rental experience.
james44
Saturday, December 28, 2024 -- 4:20 AM
I am here to transform yourI am here to transform your journey with outstanding Sabiha Gokcen Airport Lounge services. Our lounges are designed to offer a peaceful retreat away from the busy airport environment. Indulge in complimentary snacks, high-speed internet, and plush seating arrangements, all tailored to provide maximum comfort and convenience.
Whether you're on a business trip or a leisure getaway, our lounge is the ideal space to relax, catch up on work, or recharge before your flight. With a focus on superior service and first-class amenities, I ensure your time at Sabiha Gokcen Airport is stress-free and enjoyable. Let me make your pre-flight experience both relaxing and memorable.
james44
Thursday, January 2, 2025 -- 10:17 AM
I provide exceptional ParisI provide exceptional Paris tour services, offering customized and unforgettable experiences throughout the city. Explore world-renowned landmarks like the Eiffel Tower, secret spots, and exclusive events, all tailored to your unique interests. With experienced local guides, flexible tours, and a commitment to luxury and comfort, every detail is designed to enhance your journey. Whether you prefer private tours or small group experiences, I ensure a seamless and enriching Paris adventure. For more information, just visit the website.
D. Chaney
Monday, January 13, 2025 -- 7:11 PM
I appreciate this insightfulI appreciate this insightful discussion on assimilation vs. integration! It's crucial to recognize the balance between adopting core societal values while preserving cultural identities. This reminds me of the interactive game, bad parenting , which cleverly explores the challenges of navigating cultural expectations. Engaging with diverse perspectives can enrich our communities, making integration not just a requirement but a celebration of diversity. How can we better encourage these multifaceted cultural exchanges in daily life?
tawave1622
Wednesday, January 22, 2025 -- 10:30 AM
When it comes to reliable carWhen it comes to reliable car rental services in Dubai, Lavish Cars is a name that stands out. Whether you're visiting for business or pleasure, their extensive fleet of luxury vehicles ensures you'll find the perfect ride. From high-performance sports cars to spacious SUVs, Lavish Cars offers exceptional options tailored to your preferences. With transparent pricing, easy booking, and outstanding customer support, their car rental services are designed to provide you with a hassle-free and luxurious driving experience while you explore everything Dubai has to offer.
tawave1622
Wednesday, January 22, 2025 -- 10:31 AM
For those seeking the bestFor those seeking the best car rental in Dubai, Lavish Cars is the ultimate choice. Known for its top-tier fleet of luxury vehicles, Lavish Cars ensures you enjoy a driving experience like no other. Whether you're attending a business event, exploring Dubai’s iconic landmarks, or just looking to add a touch of luxury to your stay, Lavish Cars offers the perfect solution. Their commitment to excellent customer service and attention to detail sets them apart as one of the most reliable and prestigious car rental providers in Dubai.
h89u0j
Friday, January 24, 2025 -- 8:44 AM
NURS FPX 4030 Assessment 2NURS FPX 4030 Assessment 2
Succeed in NURS FPX 4030 Assessment 2 with direction from master coaches at experttutors.info. Our devoted experts give customized help, guaranteeing your nursing tasks fulfill the most elevated scholastic guidelines. Visit us today to begin on your way to progress.