The First English Feminist

17 November 2023

For the next installment in our Wise Women series, we’re talking about the life and thought of Mary Astell, an early feminist pioneer writing in England at the turn of the 18th century. She argued that women are men’s intellectual equals, encouraged women not to marry, and proposed that they go to an all-women’s school instead.

And she defended this proto-feminism with some really cool arguments. For instance, to defend women’s equality, she appealed to Cartesian dualism—the idea that your mind is a completely separate substance from your body. This was a central theme in our previous Wise Women episode on Elisabeth of Bohemia, who was skeptical and pushed back against Descartes in her letters to him. But Astell believed in dualism and used it as a basis for her feminism. Men’s and women’s bodies are different, she said, but their minds are fundamentally the same: equally rational, and equally capable of intellectual virtue.

This was no doubt a fairly radical view at the time. In those days, most women had far less access to education, and many male thinkers said they were ruled by their passions, not their reason—too focused on the cut of their clothes and not enough on spiritual matters. And Astell had a lot to say about that. She thought it was true that women were often vain and silly, but she blamed society, not women's essential natures. Everybody kept telling them they were only valuable for being pretty, and then criticized them for only caring about their looks. If you want women to care about important things, Astell said, you have to educate them.

And she tried to create a school to do just that. In her book A Serious Proposal to the Ladies, she describes how it would work: Women would live together in a retreat away from “vain insignificant men.” They would study philosophy, develop supportive friendships, and cultivate their virtue together. She was hoping to find a wealthy patron to sponsor this retreat, but unfortunately she couldn't secure the funding (not that we'd know anything about that...).

But she didn’t give up! She wrote a Part Two, which explained a method for achieving virtue even if you’re not able to attend a retreat or surround yourself with supportive friends. And if you follow her method, you can achieve virtue no matter who you are. You can cultivate your understanding so it starts taking charge of your will, showing you what’s really important to care about. Instead of worrying about the latest fashions, you’ll spend time studying the best books (and, we like to think, radio shows).

Astell certainly sounds rather ahead of her time: she believed in women’s rational nature, advocated for supportive female friendships, and criticized sexist double standards. She also told women not to get married, so they wouldn’t have to be bossed around by their husbands. Yet at the same time she also told them that if they did get married, they just had to accept their subordinate status. And she felt the same way towards the monarchy and the church: she said you had to obey them, even if their dictates were objectively wrong. This was in direct opposition to John Locke, who was writing around the same time, and spoke of the right to rebel when our monarchs are tyrannical and arbitrary. Astell disagreed: you've got to obey God in the sky, king on the throne, and husband in the home.

It can be difficult to reconcile all of Astell’s ideas. She argues that women are just as capable of rationality as men, and even says that in a lot of ways women are more virtuous than men. So why does she let husbands boss their wives around? That's among the things we'll ask our guest, Allauren Forbes from McMaster University, author of many articles including The Oxford Bibliography on Mary Astell.

Comments (9)

RalfKortig's picture


Monday, January 8, 2024 -- 10:47 AM

At a time when women's

At a time when women's intellectual capacities were frequently underestimated, Astell boldly asserted that women were not only men's equals but also possessed the potential for intellectual excellence.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
misspaloma's picture


Wednesday, March 27, 2024 -- 4:49 PM

Regarding Allauren Forbes'

Regarding Allauren Forbes' perspective, as an expert on Mary Astell and author of various articles on the subject, she likely offers insights into Astell's work within its historical context. Her views may shed light on the complexities of Astell's ideas and how they intersect with broader societal norms and expectations.

Miss Paloma, Sydney Dance School

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
maybelledicks's picture


Tuesday, April 23, 2024 -- 6:11 AM

great post

great post

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Davidandrew2134's picture


Tuesday, May 21, 2024 -- 4:06 AM

Bridgerton Simon Basset

Bridgerton Simon Basset Tailcoat is not only for some special event you may try it anywhere and any gathering why i am suggesting you because of its quality. when you wear this on winter you will feel warm and stay healthy

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
omarepps's picture


Thursday, May 30, 2024 -- 7:45 AM

When it comes to fashion,

When it comes to fashion, every woman knows that while beauty is inherent, confidence can be crafted. Quality and style in clothing play a crucial role in enhancing this confidence. Personally, I have always preferred clothing from Home Lee, a brand that epitomizes both style and quality, ensuring that every piece I wear adds to my self-assurance.

Fabric Quality and Comfort
The first step in choosing great clothing is assessing the quality of the fabric. Home Lee uses premium materials that stand the test of time and maintain comfort throughout the day. Whether it's the softness of their cotton or the durability of their blends, each piece is designed with everyday wear in mind.

Fit and Elegance
A perfect fit is key to looking and feeling great. Home Lee offers a diverse range of sizes and fits that cater to every body type, ensuring that every woman can find pieces that fit perfectly and flatter her figure. This attention to fit not only enhances your natural silhouette but also promotes a poised appearance that's essential for confidence.

Style and Versatility
Home Lee’s collections feature a versatile array of styles that can seamlessly transition from day to night, from casual to formal. Their designs blend classic elements with modern trends, making it easy to find pieces that resonate with personal style while remaining adaptable to various occasions.

In today’s fashion world, sustainability is more important than ever. Opting for brands like home lee that are committed to ethical practices not only contributes to environmental sustainability but also allows you to wear each piece with pride, knowing your choices support responsible fashion.

Personal Recommendation
From my own experience, wearing Home Lee not only enhances my external appearance but also bolsters my internal confidence. The right outfit can transform your day, giving you an extra boost of confidence when you need it most. For those interested in exploring Home Lee’s collection, visit BoxHill’s website to discover pieces that can redefine your wardrobe.

In conclusion, selecting the right women's clothing is about much more than just keeping up with trends. It's about finding pieces that resonate with your personal identity and lifestyle. Home Lee offers that perfect blend of quality, style, and confidence, making it my go-to choice for women’s fashion. Remember, when you feel confident in your clothing, it shows.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Alex_rodger's picture


Thursday, July 4, 2024 -- 5:19 AM

Make a bold statement with

Make a bold statement with the Beetlejuice Beetlejuice Suit! Perfect for Halloween parties or cosplay conventions, this suit will help you capture the spirit of Michael Keaton’s iconic character. Order yours now!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
kevinlevin's picture


Monday, July 15, 2024 -- 3:00 AM

This Rip Wheeler jacket is

This Rip Wheeler jacket is the real deal! The craftsmanship is top-notch, and it looks just like the one in
the show. A great buy for any fan.
yellowstone rip wheeler jacket

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
kevinlevin's picture


Monday, July 15, 2024 -- 3:01 AM

"Wearing Ted Lasso's jackets

"Wearing Ted Lasso's jackets is like wearing a badge of honor for positivity. They're stylish yet grounded in the show's message of resilience and teamwork. It's more than just fashion—it's a reminder to approach life with a can-do attitude."
ted lasso puffer jacket

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
mayaaiko00's picture


Tuesday, July 23, 2024 -- 1:04 AM

thats true, Mary Astell made

thats true, Mary Astell made a strong case for women's equality in education and self-improvement, arguing that they are just as intellectually capable to be men. like the wear Stussy Hoodie for women can feel the confident in this society

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines