The Tao of Zhuangzi

03 November 2023

Zhuangzi is a famous Taoist philosopher from fourth-century-BCE China, known for his brilliance, his paradoxes, and his pithy aphorisms. Here’s one: 

“When people sleep in a damp place, they wake up deathly ill. But what about eels?
If people live in trees, they tremble with fear and worry. But how about monkeys?
Of these three, which knows what is the ‘right’ place to live?” 

Zhuangzi’s Confucian contemporaries thought there was a single good way to be a human being: respect your elders, uphold order, perform all the proper rituals, be benevolent and responsible, and perfectly inhabit your social role. But Zhuangzi profoundly disagreed. There’s no such thing as the one good way to be, he thought, since each of us has different needs. (“From the point of view of the Way, no thing is more valuable than any other.”) And as for our social roles, who says it’s good to be useful?

Zhuangzi’s key example was a useless tree, really bad at performing its social role—so gnarly and twisted that no carpenter could use it for anything. So it survived, while all the other trees got cut down and turned into lumber. “Everyone knows how useful usefulness is,” quipped Zhuangzi, “but no one seems to know how useful uselessness is.”

Meanwhile, even if we are trying to figure out what is good and what is bad for us, we shouldn’t do that by listening to authority figures. Zhuangzi tells of a man swimming in a raging waterfall. Someone asks how he got so good at swimming, and he says nobody taught him; he just followed his inborn nature. A good reminder, thinks Zhuangzi, that there’s no point listening to teachers.

So we have a sage telling us not to listen to sages; his advice is not to listen to advice; there’s a practice, but it doesn’t involve practice; and it’s good for us, except that nothing is good or bad. Does that all make sense?

Well, the whole point of Zhuangzi is to get beyond questions like that. As he himself puts it, “What man knows is far less than what he does not know. It is because he tries to exhaust this vastness with this meagerness that he bewilders and frustrates himself.” We need to stop trying to encompass everything with those feeble minds of ours. And more generally, we need to calm down and stop striving. If everyone did that, there would be no war, or greed, or oppression.

On the other hand, it’s not clear there would be a ton of joy, either. The universe, says Zhuangzi, “burdens me with a physical form, labors me with life, eases me with old age, rests me with death.” If death is a relief, Zhuangzi’s way of life doesn’t sound like a particularly cheerful existence. Confucians might add that it’s a recipe for confusion, apathy, or even bad behavior. And philosophers like us might say it deprives us of the fun we have in thinking hard about the world.

But we’re going to have fun being talked out of all that by our guest: Paul Kjellberg from Whittier College, editor of Essays on Skepticism, Relativism, and Ethics in The Zhuangzi. He's an excellent teacher. Wait—does that mean we shouldn't listen to him?

Comments (6)


Josh Landy's picture

Josh Landy

Friday, February 9, 2024 -- 1:34 PM

A listener has kindly asked

A listener has kindly asked us to provide references for the quotations—thank you, listner! They are drawn from Zhuangzi: The Essential Writings, translated by Brook Ziporyn.

Chapters and sections are as follows:

“When people sleep in a damp place, they wake up deathly ill. But what about eels?
If people live in trees, they tremble with fear and worry. But how about monkeys?
Of these three, which knows what is the ‘right’ place to live?” (2:38)

“From the point of view of the Way, no thing is more valuable than any other.” (ch. 17, page 71; spoken by Ruo)

“Everyone knows how useful usefulness is, but no one seems to know how useful uselessness is.” (4:20)

“What man knows is far less than what he does not know. It is because he tries to exhaust this vastness with this meagerness that he bewilders and frustrates himself.” (chapter 17, page 70; spoken by Ruo)

“The Great Clump burdens me with a physical form, labors me with life, eases me with old age, rests me with death.” (6:24, 6:41)

Thanks again for the question!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Howboys's picture

Howboys

Thursday, July 18, 2024 -- 3:27 PM

house of hazardsis the

house of hazardsis the perfect choice for those who want to entertain after stressful hours of study and work. Just a few minutes of playing the game, you will feel refreshed and full of energy.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
avanda2w's picture

avanda2w

Saturday, September 14, 2024 -- 4:44 PM

It is amazing how Zhuangzi's

It is amazing how Zhuangzi's philosophy challenges conventional ideas about life and wisdom. His paradoxical approach and critique of societal norms really makes us reconsider the value of what we normally consider useful or necessary. By the way, if you are like me and like to philosophize to music, I recommend this site https://getmp3.one .It is useful for accessing a wide range of music and audio files. It is easy to use and offers high quality content that is perfect for a variety of needs.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Asterios's picture

Asterios

Monday, October 21, 2024 -- 1:10 PM

The Tao of Zhuangzi was a

The Tao of Zhuangzi was a great philosopher who made quite a few discoveries and gave us a lot of cool ideas that modern philosophers might not have come up with. I found out about him while telling my friend about a great website https://fish-prawn-crab.com/ that gives users a lot of bonuses when registering and allows you to withdraw funds instantly

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Luisard's picture

Luisard

Monday, November 4, 2024 -- 2:23 PM

I recently had an incredible

I recently had an incredible experience at Casino, especially enjoying the variety of slots slots available. The atmosphere is vibrant and welcoming, with friendly staff ready to assist at any moment. Each slot machine offers unique themes and exciting bonus features that kept me entertained for hours. I particularly loved the progressive jackpots that added an extra thrill to the gameplay. If you're looking for a fun night out filled with exciting slots and great energy, this is the place to be! Highly recommend!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Angel17's picture

Angel17

Tuesday, November 12, 2024 -- 7:01 PM

Thanks for sharing

Thanks for sharing information about him. Keep posting! Lanai Screen Repair Riverview FL

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines