The Debt Crisis
Wednesday, February 24, 2016 -- 4:00 PM
John Perry

International Debt, the debts that nations, often quite poor, owe to other nations and banks, is leading to disaster.  There is something like 200 trillion dollars worth of such debt, and 24 nations in crisis because they can’t pay off their debts.  The burden of debt falls on the poor and disenfranchised, as debtor nations impose taxes and cut back benefits.  We’re talking massive human tragedy unfolding around the world.

Debt seems a very useful institution, and if usurious practices are under control, basically just.  You have a debtor, who borrows money and promises to repay it with interest.  You have a creditor, who loans the money, and expects to get repaid with interest.  As long as everyone is a reasonably rational agent --- no children or crazy people involved --- it seems a straightforward, fair, and extremely useful human institution.  It allowed me to buy a house; it allows students from backwards countries like America to get a college education.

But this model doesn’t scale up to cases in which nations and other institutions are the lenders and borrowers.  The model assumes that the same agent takes out the loan and then later has to repay it or incur the consequences.   That’s a key part of the fairness of the institution of debt∂.  But that’s not what happens when countries take out loans.

These debts can last for a long time.  One group of leaders may negotiate the loan, and use the money to make themselves popular, by using the money to provide benefits to their constituents. Another group is faced with paying it off, years or even generations later, by taxing and reducing benefits for another group of constituents.

 We can call the nation “agent” doesn’t change the facts.  Loans are negotiated by people, and it’s people that have make the painful decision to repay them or not. That’s where the real agency lies, whatever we call “the agent.  And there is a difference between expecting to repay a loan yourself, and expecting someone down the line, who happens to be a part of the same institution or nation as you are, to pay it. 

When people make decisions to lend or borrow on behalf of institutions, you get two sets of costs and benefits --- on both sides of the deal.  A bank’s agent may get short term benefits for being the one who negotiates the loan, independently of whether in the longer term the loan gets paid off.

The model of a just loan agreement will work if everyone acts rationally relative to the costs and benefits to the whole group to institution represents, rather than their own.  But that doesn’t always happen.  It didn’t happen on Wall Street.  Big banks made it advantageous to their broker to make risky gambles, which then came back to haunt the banks --- at least until we taxpayers bailed them out.

So we need a new model of just loans for nations. That’s above my paygrade to figure out. But listen to the show this week, and maybe Ken and I and our guest, UMass economist Julie Nelson, will come up with a solution.

Comments (13)


Harold G. Neuman

Thursday, February 25, 2016 -- 4:00 PM

Well, I don't want to sound

Well, I don't want to sound like some bible-thumping zealot from ultra-conservative middle America, but, to piggy back upon posts regarding religion and finding meaning in a material world, I felt sufficiently affirmed to state the following: Usury is still usury, even when it is sanctioned as business as usual. Any time a practice becomes and remains legal, particularly where the exchange of money is involved, sooner or later someone will abuse the practice and privilege. This is painfully true in banking where the too-big-to-fail maxim perpetuated the economic chaos that struck towards the end of 2008. It is also endemic for insurance of all types which I have formerly characterized as legalized extortion. The propensity of human beings to want to have everything that they can have at any cost is a character flaw which has become epidemic in the illustrious West and is rapidly catching on in other parts of the world. Sad to tell, but all of this supports my notion that, for better or worse, we get pretty much what we deserve, i.e., we both prosper and suffer from the effects of history. Inasmuch as we have put ourselves in harms way, trading unfettered prosperity for cautious stability and long-term sustainability, the djinn is out of the bottle and we have no mechanism through which we might put him back. If Keynes is not tossing in his grave, he damned well should be.
Neuman.

Gary M Washburn

Friday, February 26, 2016 -- 4:00 PM

Let's not get into "moral

Let's not get into "moral hazard"! It's a one-sided and devious "principle". Most private loans are secured by collateral or some insurance plan anyway, so the lender is just being perverse in pressing that damn point. But I think the topic is public borrowing. Think Greece or Nauru, not credit-card debt. Greeks and Romans despised usury because they assumed money was stable and believed lending would destroy nobles and elevate the 'ignoble' into their position in society. It also smacked of the power to tax, which any government is rightly jealous of. But that is the real issue, isn't it? Doesn't predatory lending assert a kind of sovereignty, not only demanding repayment, but control over public policy? During the Cold War there was a lot of lending to corrupt regimes who promised to oppose the other side. Today most of these countries are coming to their senses, though some exceptions may be notable. But the problem today is more a matter of lenders insinuating themselves into decisions that are properly the prerogative of the people of the borrowing nation, and their leaders, not the bankers they owe money to. Speaking to the philosophy of it, the quantification of value is a contradiction in terms.

JeannineParker

Sunday, March 13, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

I am genuinely happy to read

I am genuinely happy to read this blog posts which
includes tons of valuable facts, thanks for providing such data.
http://www.proessaywriting.com/

Guest

Monday, March 28, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Thank you very much for

Thank you very much for sharing with us all, hopefully better future and success always for your website
Obat Kolesterol

Guest

Tuesday, March 29, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Thank you for sharing the

Thank you for sharing the information with usOBAT DARAH TINGGIObat HerniaObat Hernia Tanpa Operasi Alami Herbal Tradisional obat herniaObat StrokeObat Asam UratObat HerniaObat Darah TinggiObat Darah TinggiObat Darah TinggiObat SinusitisObat SinusitisObat InsomniaObat InsomniaObat Kurang DarahObat Kurang DarahObat MaagObat MaagObat MaagObat MaagObat Usus Buntu
obat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat strokeobat stroke
obat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maagobat maag
obat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggiobat darah tinggi
obat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam uratobat asam urat

Guest

Tuesday, March 29, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Obat Kolesterol Obat Hidrokel

Obat Kolesterol
Obat Hidrokel

Pedestrian

Sunday, April 3, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Actually I have to agree with

Actually I have to agree with our modern financial philosophers, without debt...there is no money. Debt within the micro economic sphere is most often a tool and short term, i.e., it's paid off. However, debt at the macroeconomic level partially defines moral hazard. It is patently immoral for a country's leaders to borrow money and put generations of his country's population often into perpetual debt. In fact, debt has become the chains that binds us all, as far too many economies have become cost-of-capital sensitive, leading [its] performance to become directly proportional to and dependent upon, a customer's ability to borrow the money.The debt crisis will lead to continued world recession and if not reduced...world depression.
 
 
 
 

Guest

Tuesday, May 17, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

it was amazing the contents

it was amazing the contents of the articles you post , it is very beneficial to me personally . thank youOBAT HERNIA OBAT ASAM URAT OBAT DARAH TINGGI OBAT KEPUTIHAN OBAT MAAG OBAT STROKE OBAT KEPUTIHAN

newtonmoses

Wednesday, May 25, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

I agree with you that most

I agree with you that most countries face debt crises and as such, it is about time that all the stakeholders concerned came together and devised a new model of just loans for nations. I like the way that you have backed your argument with verifiable facts. You can now get article review writing help by simply clicking on this link: Article Review Writing Assistance

Guest

Monday, June 20, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Hopefully today you and this

Hopefully today you and this website was given a long success you aspire. Obat Penyubur Sperma

Guest

Saturday, June 25, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

I like the content of the

I like the content of the article so much. It is nice and great to get hit into that. Philosophy is made of the two words philo and sophia which has been derived from latin words.

Guest

Saturday, June 25, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

I am so thankful to the

I am so thankful to the author to bring this article over here. I like the topic so much std testing on low cost near me so that I would be really thankful to them so glad to be here as std testing new york clinics to join have some great day ahead.

sanathpollemore

Friday, July 8, 2016 -- 5:00 PM

Portugal Visa UKSwitzerland

Portugal Visa UKSwitzerland Visa UKBelgium Visa UKGermany Visa UKRussia Visa UK

 
 
 

Blog Archive

2018

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2017

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2016

December

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2015

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March

February

January

2005

December

November

October

September

August

July

June

May

April

March