Thinking and Mental Action

02 April 2020

Here’s something you’ll know if you’ve ever sat through a boring lecture: sometimes your mind simply goes wherever it will. Thoughts of different kinds come to you, one after the other, linked by mere association. At one moment you’re daydreaming about your new puppy; in the next, you suddenly recall that “W.H.O. let the dogs out” tweet; moments after, you sit through a mental rendition of the classic Baha Men song; and from there, you have flashes of your misspent youth. When your thoughts freely transition one to the next in this way, we sometimes say your mind is ‘wandering.’ 

 

But that’s not the only way your thoughts can proceed. Contrast this meandering with a period of tight mental focus—say, when you’re hard at work figuring out the answer to 12 Down in a crossword puzzle. In this case, your mind doesn’t just go anywhere it likes. In this case, your thoughts stay on one topic, approaching it from several angles; the series of your thoughts has a more circumscribed path. You might consider one option for filling the word out (say, FROTH), and then think FDR might go into 12 Across, but then ANGST wouldn’t fit in 13 Down, as it needs to do, so then you reject FROTH as the answer to 12 Down and consider BROTH, and so on. 

 

So far we’ve just marked one clear—but somewhat superficial—difference between mind-wandering and crossword-solving. In mind-wandering, you can take a mental walk through various topics that are only loosely connected by association. In crossword-solving, on the other hand, your thoughts are focused on one specific topic. What explains this superficial difference? 

 

What explains this superficial difference is a deeper difference between these two cases. It’s the difference between not doing much of anything at all and doing something in thought: engaging in some mental action.  

 

The kind of mind-wandering I described is a mode of thought in which you don’t control the topics of your thoughts. By contrast, in solving a crossword puzzle you’re engaged in a specific action: you are solving the 12 Down clue. You might do it with a particular purpose (e.g. the purpose of solving the whole crossword, or the purpose of having fun), and you might use specific strategies to carry it out (e.g. thinking of all the words you know that end in -OTH). It requires effort and concentration. 

 

Importantly, when you’re solving the 12 Down clue, you control the topics of your thoughts. You couldn’t really act if you didn’t have some control; if some unseen or outside forces completely determined the contents and flow of your thoughts, there wouldn’t be any room for you to play a role. So part of what it is to say that solving the clue for 12 Down is an action is to say that you are exercising control here—in particular, in control over your thoughts.

 

This explains why your thoughts don’t ‘wander’ through different topics in this case. Part of the control you’re exercising is control over what you are thinking about. If you were to start thinking about something else in the crossword case, you would snap back your attention to the task at hand. Not so in the case of mind-wandering: there, you aren’t restricting your attention at all, but just sitting idly by while it flits from one topic to another. 

 

This raises another natural question: what does control involve here? 

 

In this case, as in many others, acting with control seems to involve representing what you’re trying to do. In other words, you have an idea of what you’re trying to do. Here, that idea represents what you are trying to as “solving the clue for 12 Down.” This idea of what you’re trying to do is central to control, because it helps you snap back on task when (e.g.) your thoughts begin to drift toward Baha Men music again. If you didn’t keep in mind any idea of what you were trying to do, when those catchy lines slipped into your stream of consciousness, you would simply forget—and thereby abandon—your prior mental task. 

 

If we accept that (i) mental action requires control and (ii) control requires an idea of what you’re trying to do, we come to a striking conclusion: when you’re engaged in mental action, we can describe both the stream of thought you are engaged in, and the way you’re thinking of what you’re doing, as two crucial aspects of your mental life and its significance for you. If I interrupted you during your thoughts about 12 Down and asked what you were thinking, you might just report the pieces of language that show up in your thoughts (“FROTH… BROTH… CLOTH…”). After all, words are at the center of your focus when you’re completing a crossword. But this isn’t mere idle free association; at the same time, you understand what you’re doing and a full story of your mental life at this moment would need to mention this as well. I might ask you: “Why are you thinking those things?” and you might say: “oh, I’m considering them as answers to 12 Down.”

 

To use a metaphor, we might say that there are two layers to your thought when you are engaged in mental action: there’s the content of your thoughts, or what you’re thinking—FROTH, then BROTH, then CLOTH—and then there’s the layer of self-understanding that represents what you are trying to do all along, as “figuring out the answer to 12 Down.”

 

This is just one of the reasons that mental action matters in philosophy. When we describe a stream of thoughts as part of an ongoing action, we thereby imply that there’s an overarching structure to your thought that controls its direction. You do this by keeping in mind what you’re trying to do. And that implies that—unlike in mind-wandering—the significance of each of your individual thoughts (e.g. the thought of “FROTH”) is not just local, a little island on which your attention has alighted for a brief pause. The significance to you is much greater than that. Each of your thoughts might have some local content (“FROTH” or “BROTH” or “CLOTH”) but you also see it as playing a role in the larger mental project in which you are engaged.

Comments (17)


Tim Smith's picture

Tim Smith

Thursday, April 2, 2020 -- 3:32 PM

What is this mental control

What is this mental control indeed? It would seem the origin of the model of your focused self is as mysterious as that our your wandering mind. I doubt I could think any other thought than the one I am thinking now.

There is a difference though. Just not sure models or over arching structure are required to delineate them. Models themselves need their own identity and validity separate from our concept of self.

This was a good read. Thanks.

jasperwilde09's picture

jasperwilde09

Thursday, February 29, 2024 -- 1:36 AM

The article is very good and

The article is very good and profound, I often let my mind wander or sometimes concentrate completely
Can you add articles about how the brain needs to rest after long periods of absolute focus and avoid letting your mind wander? enneagram test Thank you

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
imposeshortbread's picture

imposeshortbread

Friday, July 19, 2024 -- 2:01 AM

Can you add articles

Can you add articles regarding how the brain needs to eggy car recuperate after lengthy periods of absolute focus

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
andersonjack's picture

andersonjack

Wednesday, October 9, 2024 -- 3:13 AM

If your SASSA (South African

If your SASSA (South African Social Security Agency) identity verification has failed, it can delay or prevent you from receiving your grants. This issue commonly arises when the personal information you provided doesn’t match the data in SASSA’s system, such as your ID number, name, or other details. how do i fix my sassa identity verification Fortunately, there are steps you can take to fix this issue. To resolve the identity verification failure, you will need to check your personal details for accuracy, update any incorrect information, and follow specific procedures outlined by SASSA. For more details, you can visit this guide to help fix your SASSA identity verification.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
hvris's picture

hvris

Friday, October 11, 2024 -- 12:42 PM

This article really resonated

This article really resonated with me. When dealing with SASSA, it's easy to get distracted and lose focus. I've found that staying organized and setting clear goals helps me stay on track. It's like solving a puzzle; you need to piece together all the information and requirements for a successful application. Just remember to keep your mind focused and avoid getting sidetracked, especially during the SASSA identity verification process.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
andersonjack's picture

andersonjack

Sunday, November 10, 2024 -- 1:33 AM

cannoli queen amanda

cannoli queen amanda labollita has carved out a unique place in the culinary world with her mastery of Italian desserts, particularly cannoli. Through her Instagram handle @cannoli_queen, Amanda shares stunning visuals of her traditional and innovative takes on Italian pastries. Her dedication to authenticity and high-quality ingredients, combined with her engaging content, has earned her a loyal following of dessert lovers. Known for blending old-world flavors with modern twists, Amanda's creations have made her a prominent influencer in the realm of Italian sweets​

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
sunflower36002's picture

sunflower36002

Monday, November 18, 2024 -- 12:46 AM

Uncover the rich traditions

Uncover the rich traditions and izithakazelo (praises) of the Mdletshe clan, celebrating their cultural heritage. Mdletshe Clan Names

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
wjames's picture

wjames

Wednesday, November 20, 2024 -- 10:42 PM

This article really resonated

This article really resonated with me. When dealing with SASSA identity verification, staying organized and focused is key. It’s like solving a puzzle – you need to piece together all the information for a successful application. Staying on track, especially during the identity verification, helps avoid distractions.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
andersonjack's picture

andersonjack

Friday, November 22, 2024 -- 4:46 AM

When it comes to thinking and

When it comes to thinking and mental action, it's about clarity, focus, and the right tools to enhance both. Just like how our minds need the right strategies to stay sharp and efficient, choosing the right device for your vaping experience can make a significant difference. The Voopoo Argus G2 is a prime example of how modern technology can elevate your everyday activities. Its advanced features, coupled with great performance, make it a valuable tool for anyone looking to get the most out of their vaping sessions. Whether you're a seasoned vaper or just starting out, understanding the voopoo argus g2 priceand investing in the right device can bring you both satisfaction and simplicity, just like sharpening your mind with the right mental approach.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
andersonjack's picture

andersonjack

Friday, November 29, 2024 -- 3:19 AM

Drive Zone Online Mod APK is

Drive Zone Online Mod APK is not just a game; it's a gateway to a world of thinking and mental action. With its immersive gameplay and advanced features, the game challenges players to strategize, plan, and execute their moves like never before. From realistic driving physics to unlocking VIP perks, this mod version enhances the experience, making every decision critical and rewarding.

Whether you're navigating intense traffic scenarios, participating in high-stakes races, or mastering the art of perfect parking, Drive zone online mod apk sharpens your mental agility while keeping the thrill alive. Download it today to elevate your gaming journey and embrace a new realm of cognitive engagement!

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
hvrrix's picture

hvrrix

Sunday, December 1, 2024 -- 10:46 AM

This is a fascinating

This is a fascinating exploration of how we control our thoughts during focused tasks versus letting them wander. It’s interesting how mental action, like solving a crossword puzzle, involves not only the thoughts we have but also the awareness of what we're trying to achieve. It really shows how control and intention shape our mental processes!
You may like to learn more at: https://joripress.com/how-sassa-grants-drive-economic-resilience-in-sout...
https://yoo.social/read-blog/88774
https://teamcnut.com/123792-2/

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
daddau's picture

daddau

Saturday, December 14, 2024 -- 3:52 AM

This post brilliantly

This post brilliantly distinguishes between mind-wandering and focused mental action, emphasizing the role of control and intentionality in guiding our thoughts. The metaphor of two layers—content and self-understanding—beautifully captures the structured nature of mental action, offering a fresh perspective on how our thoughts gain significance within broader goals. Learn more a: Online Sassa Status Check co za

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
@michal_007's picture

@michal_007

Wednesday, December 18, 2024 -- 7:44 AM

GB WhatsApp offers enhanced

GB WhatsApp offers enhanced messaging features, including custom themes and privacy options like hiding blue ticks and online status.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
gtrde's picture

gtrde

Tuesday, January 21, 2025 -- 11:31 PM

Just as in mental tasks like

In both gaming and real-life tasks, staying focused plays a crucial role in success. For example, in Drive Zone Online, your mind remains engaged as you navigate through the course, making quick decisions and adjusting your strategy, much like when you focus on solving a challenging puzzle. Each move you make in the game is connected to a broader goal, demonstrating how focus and control shape the outcome of your actions. To explore more about this, Visit Now https://dzoneonline.com/.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Timothy's picture

Timothy

Tuesday, January 28, 2025 -- 1:12 AM

The way you organized the

The way you organized the information made it so easy to follow, and your schoolboy runaway ability to connect the dots for readers is truly impressive.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
sunflower36002's picture

sunflower36002

Monday, February 10, 2025 -- 12:03 AM

FM WhatsApp download

FM WhatsApp download provides the latest FM WhatsApp APK, offering advanced privacy settings, customization options, and improved media sharing capabilities.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
sunflower36002's picture

sunflower36002

Monday, February 10, 2025 -- 12:12 AM

GB WhatsApp download offers

GB WhatsApp download offers the official, updated GB WhatsApp APK with enhanced features like customization options, advanced privacy settings, and anti-ban protection.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines