Sorry, Critics: Parasite is a Good Movie

02 March 2020

 

I hope you’ve had a chance to see Parasite, the wonderful film by South Korean director Bong Joon-ho. For me—as for the good people at the Oscars—it was far and away the best film of 2019. Other people, however, are eagerly denouncing Parasite as a failure, a capitulation, a “conservative” film, indeed a movie full of “contempt” for the working class. What is going on?

 

(Spoilers ahead!)

 

Here’s what the critics think. First of all, they think that Parasite is a movie with a message. Maybe this is because they assume all serious movies have messages, or maybe it’s something specific about Parasite; either way, they take it for granted that Bong Joon-ho is trying to “say” something, “show” something, "send a message,” “teach a lesson,” “make a statement.” The New Yorker tells us that Bong “made the movie with the desire, the will, to show something that he has in mind.” The Nation talks about “Bong’s message.” The LA Review of Books asks whether it has “anything original to say.”

 

But sending messages, showing something, and having original things to say, are things you have to do if you’re a journalist or a scholar. They’re not things you have to do if you’re a fiction-writer. They are what you should want from philosophers and historians and social theorists. They are not things you should always demand of movie-makers—even serious ones. Serious, ambitious, even socially committed fiction-makers don’t always teach lessons: they often ask questions, questions to which they refuse to provide answers. They force us to think for ourselves.

 

That’s how Toni Morrison thought of her own writing. “Classical music,” she said, “satisfies and closes. Black music does not do that…. There is no final chord. There may be a long chord, but there is no final chord. And it agitates you. Spirituals agitate you, no matter what they are saying about how it is all going to be. There is something underneath them that is incomplete. There is always something else that you want from the music. I want my books to be like that.” Bong Joon-ho, to his credit, has said something very similar: he wants viewers of his movie to “tal[k] over all the ideas they had while watching it”—not to have their minds changed in a particular direction.

 

So it’s a mistake to think of Bong’s movie as a work designed to tell people what to think. Part of what prevents Parasite from being a simple morality tale is that the rich characters aren’t entirely terrible and the poor characters aren’t entirely saintly. The central poor characters (the Kim family) are vastly preferable to the rich characters (the Park family), but they are flawed human beings. What has today’s legion of critics concluded from this? That Bong is trying to tell us something, of course, and what he’s trying to tell us is: the poor deserve what they get.

 

I hope you find that surprising if you’ve watched the movie, but I promise you, it’s exactly what the LA Review tells us: “Parasite delivers uncensored class contempt…. Parasite implies throughout that the Parks are at the top and the Kims at the bottom of the social ladder for good reason.” (The Parks don’t fold pizza boxes well, so apparently they deserve to live in a slum.) The Nation agrees: “their suffering… is rationalized by their vulgarity and unscrupulousness.” Rationalized!

 

This idea is already staggeringly false about the Kims: maybe they aren’t enormously motivated to fold pizza boxes, but they are clearly resourceful and sharp. And then again, they are not the only impoverished characters in the film: there’s also the original housekeeper, Moon-gwang, who is surely neither lazy nor unscrupulous. (Most viewers will probably root for the Kims over Moon-gwang. Some will stop to wonder why they did so. And this complexity is a strength of the film, not a weakness.)

 

If you want to make people think and talk by means of your movie, it’s a good idea to include elements of ambiguity. That includes moral complexity. If, in Parasite, the poor characters are not utterly saintly and the rich characters are not utterly villainous, this is not because the movie is failing to be a good morality tale: it’s because it’s succeeding at being complicated.

 

So no, the poor characters in the film are not presented as deserving their fate. And no, this is not a “message” about poor people everywhere, telling us that all of them are lazy and unscrupulous and deserve everything that’s coming to them. Parasite is not an allegory, in which the characters stand for All Poor People. They are particular fictional people, not archetypes. We are not supposed to base our views of poor people on what the Kims and Moon-gwang do in this film. And even these specific characters are not presented as deserving to live in the gutter.

 

The critics got it wrong about what the film is trying to do; as we saw, that led some of them to say very strange things about how the Kims are presented. And it also led to a third invented complaint: that the movie is too simple. Parasite, The New Yorker tells us, is nothing but “spot-on messaging and calculated talking points, aimed at critics and viewers who share this clearly defined perspective.” It’s just preaching to the choir. It’s dull and constraining, leaving the viewer nothing to do. Really? I guess if you completely miss all the complexity, you won’t do the work the movie wants you to—but that’s hardly its fault.

 

Parasite certainly does ask us whether the real parasites aren’t the rich, not the poor. Whether there can be a just society that also allows for luxury. Whether morality is possible within capitalism—as Theodor Adorno put it, whether there can be a right life in the wrong one. But it doesn’t answer those questions. If the movie were trying to teach us something, that would be a cop-out; but since the movie is trying to get us to think, it’s exactly the right thing to do.

 

The critics who’ve panned Parasite desperately wanted to see it as a morality tale. They wanted it to be “propaganda for our side,” a movie that calls people to arms against the system. That’s what The Nation meant when it complained “Here, then, is where Parasite takes us: not to the ledge of class war but to a shrug over inequality.” But that’s not what Bong is up to, any more than it’s what Toni Morrison is up to, or A.S. Byatt (“I do not have a message to give to the world, I do not wish to seduce or persuade”), or André Aciman (“my novel doesn’t have a message”), or J.M. Coetzee (“A story is not a message with a covering”), or Leïla Slimani (“There is no message. I think that literature is here to ask questions, not to answer questions”), or scores of others. Bong said it right out: “I’m not making a documentary or propaganda here.” Wouldn’t it be nice if people had listened?

Comments (24)


Tim Smith's picture

Tim Smith

Thursday, March 12, 2020 -- 4:18 AM

Not only good...but I heard

Not only good...but I heard about it first here on PT from Leslie.

Haterz hate. People think they think.

Means don't justify ends is my short take.

Absolutely not good... very good...more importantly... thought provoking.

robertcrosman@gmail.com's picture

robertcrosman@g...

Sunday, March 15, 2020 -- 2:31 PM

Watching Parasite was an

Watching Parasite was an exhilarating experience for me. The beginning was a comic treatment of what a resourceful down-and-out family could do to keep from going under - literally so, when heavy rain threatens to drown their cellar apartment. I was hooked on the various members' strategies for pulling themselves out of their mess. Then the schemes they develop to fleece the rich family were so inventive and hilariously successful that I felt a deep sympathy for their tricks, however deplorable they might otherwise seem. The rich Parks were so stupid and so materialistic that whatever happened to them seemed justified. When the Parks leave on a trip and the Kims occupy their luxurious mansion, the wanton excess of drunkenness and destructiveness they engage in worried me, however - this was them imitating the Parks' stupid excesses in a way that was unsympathetic: does affluence MAKE one stupid?
Then came more surprising plot-twists, new characters are introduced, an improbable second plot is introduced, which leads to a bloody fiasco at the end, from which neither family emerges undamaged. Death for some; jail for others. Hard, here, NOT to see it as a miniature class warfare enacted in tragicomic realism, right before our eyes.
Parasite has some affinities with the literary genre known as "picaresque," where a lower-class intelligent rogue survives and thrives by tricking and exploiting his masters, or the powers that be. It's an amoral genre, that enlists our sympathies for criminal behavior . . . up to a point. Then the picaro is either made to pay for his crimes, or he reforms and mends his ways, perhaps having improved his economic situation in the meantime. What is wonderful about Parasite is how clever and inventive the Kims are in deceiving the stupid Parks, and how clever and inventive the plot is in keeping us constantly surprised by its sudden twists. Whatever the message (if there is one) its real strength is in its artistry - its ability to make us sympathetic with a bunch of amoral rogues who'd fleece us unmercifully if we ever met up with them, and its ability to put them in a succession of situations that test and finally overwhelm their ingenuity. It's a work of art, from which a variety of different lessons might be derived, depending on the interpreter.

niri.m's picture

niri.m

Saturday, March 28, 2020 -- 7:40 AM

Is it just me or did the

Is it just me or did the stabbing scene reminded anyone of Camus' "The Stranger"?
The way Kim instinctively stabs Park in the heart and the bright sunlight.

adamusa's picture

adamusa

Tuesday, December 19, 2023 -- 5:30 PM

This movie is very good, it

This movie is very good, it shows the current social reality of the gap between rich and poor. slope

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
LucyCoffee's picture

LucyCoffee

Thursday, February 1, 2024 -- 9:55 PM

"Parasite" made history,

"Parasite" made history, winning multiple Oscars including Best Picture and sparking global acclaim. Director Bong Joon-ho's masterpiece challenged class dynamics. The film's release led to a surge of interest in Korean cinema and promoted diversity in international cinema. Its an important milestone for the development of cinema sex dolls cheap

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
priyanka's picture

priyanka

Tuesday, April 9, 2024 -- 10:31 PM

If you are in Goa, and want

If you are in Goa, and want to enjoy the most then hiring an Goa Escorts is the only thing you should opt for. Hiring an escort is not a taboo anymore because the world became quite open-minded in the last few years and lots of men actually opt for such services.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
payalbatra's picture

payalbatra

Monday, April 22, 2024 -- 11:33 PM

Before you decide to avail

Before you decide to avail our services, you need to clear your expectations from these hot babes. Call Girls in Mumbai are so skilled that they can do anything. It is totally your decision what you want them to do for you. If it is not decided, it is very difficult to focus on fun because you act based on your sensual wishes.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
johnbabu's picture

johnbabu

Wednesday, April 24, 2024 -- 10:30 PM

I often give information

I often give information through a call, belonging to the middle- class and so I decided to get to know through my teammates how to be exclusive in a task in the earlier part of life when I was hardly twenty years old. Right now, I am more than 30 years and making more business deals through my team of Goa Call Girls and male escorts. Escorts in Goa are more terrific in communication while dealing with foreign clients or Indian clients who are running their domestic outlet.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
soniyasinghania's picture

soniyasinghania

Saturday, April 27, 2024 -- 5:27 AM

Imagine taking your stunning

Imagine taking your stunning elite Escort Service in South Ex girl down to the hotel lobby and basking in the envious stares. Hold hands in the hotel restaurant, take a whiff of her exquisite perfume, and try your hardest to be the man you've always wanted to be - relaxed, in charge, and about to savor what you so well deserve - a stunning, seductive girl - all yours for the night, to consume.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
shweta01's picture

shweta01

Tuesday, April 30, 2024 -- 1:22 AM

hello [url=https://www.google

Why finding the East of Kailash Escort Service becomes such difficult and time consuming act? Well, the key reason that makes the act of exploring the Independent Escorts East Of Kailash such tough and hectic is that, Indian men are not well aware of the right sources to tap to find these companions. As such, they are happy to join hands with any escort service agency coming in its way, and doing so, they end up making the most unwanted experience, as they are deprived of the values that they deserve to get in return for their time and money.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
soniyasinghania's picture

soniyasinghania

Friday, May 10, 2024 -- 11:12 PM

If you don't want to spend

If you don't want to spend your time alone, our freelancing models are the right choice for you. Here you can find your partner for complete satisfaction. The selection of our agency for independent model Escort in Karol Bagh depends not only on the beauty of independent model Escort girls in Karol Bagh but also on their body language, manner of talking, and gestures and to make our clients familiar and clear Should be.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
rajescortservice's picture

rajescortservice

Wednesday, May 29, 2024 -- 1:16 AM

Please Visit My Personal Web

Please Visit My Personal Web Page.
Jodhpur Escorts |

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
rajescortservice's picture

rajescortservice

Wednesday, May 29, 2024 -- 1:18 AM

Hyderabad Escort Service |
I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
poonamaggarwal's picture

poonamaggarwal

Thursday, May 30, 2024 -- 12:29 PM

Thanks for Your article...it

Thanks for Your article...it gives us immense knowledge. This is a titanic mixing article. I am all around that genuinely matters content with your call girl in Ranchi

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
preety's picture

preety

Friday, May 31, 2024 -- 4:43 AM

Mumbai escort office has a

Mumbai escort office has a lot of such accompanies. Their characteristics are unique in relation to some other standard Girls. Above all else, they have solid instructive foundation. Independent Mumbai Call Girls .Since they cherish meeting individuals, they fill in as Vip accompanies. These hot angels keep up their hot body great.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
hokkoo69's picture

hokkoo69

Wednesday, June 12, 2024 -- 4:37 AM

All personal information

All personal information collected during bookings is kept confidential and deleted after the encounter. Additionally, all interactions between clients and chennai call girls are kept strictly professional to maintain boundaries.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
shkokka's picture

shkokka

Tuesday, July 9, 2024 -- 12:23 AM

Experience the unparalleled

Experience the unparalleled allure of Hyderabad Escorts, where unforgettable moments are crafted just for you. These exceptional women are not only stunning but also exude professionalism and grace. Hyderabad escorts are dedicated to fulfilling all your desires and fantasies with the utmost sensuality. Whether it's a romantic date or an adventurous night out, they are ready to make every moment special for you.

Our Escort in Hyderabad are known for their intelligence, charm, and ability to make you feel extraordinary. Their companionship promises ultimate satisfaction, leaving a lasting impression. The exclusive class of our Call Girls in Hyderabad ensures a memorable experience you will cherish forever.

For those seeking the most delightful time of their lives, our female escorts in Hyderabad are the ideal choice. Our high-class escorts are committed to meeting all your sensual needs. These attractive and professional women, with their captivating beauty and wit, guarantee an unforgettable experience in their company.

High-Class Escort Service in Hyderabad Offers Horny Girls

Our Escort Service in Hyderabad offers the best sex services in Hyderabad, Karnataka. We provide high-class escort services to our clients at very affordable prices. Hyderabad Escorts are well-educated and expertly trained for their roles. They know precisely how to make you feel comfortable and relaxed, available to hire at any time, day or night. For those looking to enjoy life to the fullest, VIP Hyderabad Escorts will provide pleasures you've never experienced before. These sexy Hyderabad Call Girls are available 24/7, ensuring you always have access to fun and excitement. Our genuine escorts are not only horny but also intelligent and smart, offering the best escort service in Hyderabad.

Wide Range of Female Escorts by Hyderabad Escort Service

We offer a diverse selection of Hyderabad Escorts, including air hostesses, housewives, college girls, and escort models. Our Hyderabad escort service is professional and well-mannered, knowing exactly how to behave with men. They aim to impress, often wearing sexy dresses and seductive lingerie. Ready to do anything for you, they love spending time with you and ensuring your happiness. From booking an appointment to catering to your needs, these amazing ladies will provide an unforgettable experience. Just let us know the type of girl you want, and we will arrange everything for you.

Escort Service in Gurgaon
Call girls Gurgaon
Escort Service in Mumbai
Lucknow escorts
Chennai escort service
Escort in Bangalore
Escort Service Pushkar
Dwarka Call Girls
Call girls Faridabad
Call Girls in Ghaziabad
Call girls Goa
Greater Noida Call Girls
Escort in Moradabad
Escort Service Muzaffarnagar
Nainital escorts
Nasirabad Escort Service
Escort Service in Panchkula
https://medium.com/@Shkokka/call-girls-in-jaipur-shkokka-c5f2fc60851a
https://call-girl-in-gurgaon.onepage.website/
https://shkokka.godaddysites.com/
https://sites.google.com/view/noidaescorts02/home
https://sites.google.com/view/puneescorts01/home
https://sites.google.com/view/indore-escorts01/home

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
lotusidofficial's picture

lotusidofficial

Thursday, July 11, 2024 -- 1:57 AM

"Create your Lotus 365 ID and

"Create your Lotus 365 ID and dive into a world of legal, secure betting. Enjoy live events, quick cashouts, and top-notch security. Sign up now!"

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
sheetaldubay2's picture

sheetaldubay2

Saturday, July 13, 2024 -- 1:16 AM

Call Girls Hyderabad is aware

Call Girls Hyderabad is aware of the demands and wishes of its clients. It offers a beautiful and warm environment. You can hire an Call Girl in that place at any time of the day. Call Girls in that place can travel with you anywhere you want to go. If you are visiting Call Girls Hyderabad for business, they can be available at your disposal A that place Call Girl can provide personalized service for both men and women. You can choose from several profiles to find the best one for you.

Hyderabad Call Girls has become very popular among renowned people, and this association's quality has increased. The Call Girl and contact females are trained to deal with the plight of different people and have learned different dialects. They are known to be very fair and enhance restless people, and they can make the client feel pampered and satisfied.

Call Girls Bangalore
Call Girls Chandigarh
Call Girls Chennai
Call Girls Dehradun
Call Girls Delhi
Call Girls Goa
Call Girls Gurgaon
Call Girls Lucknow
Call Girls Mumbai
https://sites.google.com/view/escort-call-girls-jalandhar/home
https://sites.google.com/view/jammucallgirls/home
https://sites.google.com/view/call-girl-chandigarh-near-me/home
https://sites.google.com/view/callgirllucknownearme/home
https://sites.google.com/view/dwarkacallgirlsdrive/home
https://sites.google.com/view/bold-andheri-call-girls/home
https://sites.google.com/view/faridabad-call-girls-fun/home
https://sites.google.com/view/gayacallgirl/home
https://sites.google.com/view/rishikeshcallgirlsservices/home
https://sites.google.com/view/zirakpurcallgirlservice/home
https://sites.google.com/view/delhicallgirlsnearme/home
https://sites.google.com/view/beautiful-chandigarh-call-girl/home
https://sites.google.com/view/kolkata-callgirls-service/home
https://sites.google.com/view/ranchi-call-girls-near-me/home
https://sites.google.com/view/dating-call-girls-service/home
https://sites.google.com/view/are-you-looking-for-call-girls/home
https://sites.google.com/view/ranchicallgirls/home
https://sites.google.com/view/callgirls-udaipur/home
https://sites.google.com/view/callgirlschennai1/home
https://sites.google.com/view/call-girls-mohali/home

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines