Philosopher of Action

09 January 2025

Elizabeth Anscombe was a hugely important 20th-century philosopher who worked on many topics: history, metaphysics, religion, language. But above all she was a pioneering figure in the philosophy of action, an area of philosophy that asks questions like what’s the difference between doing something on purpose and just having it happen. For instance, imagine you’re on a subway train. There’s a sudden jolt and some guy bumps into you; presumably you’re not too fussed about it. But if the train’s standing at the station and he bumps into you on purpose, that's a whole different story. This fellow be may be thinking to himself something along the lines of “I don’t like that guy—I’m going to bump into him.”

Of course it may not really make sense to imagine him forming a sentence in his head about how much he hates someone. After all, in real life we don’t go around speaking sentences to ourselves all the time—“I’m going to make a cup of tea! I’m going to think about Anscombe! I’m going to say something to my friend!” But the thought doesn’t have to be in words; there just has to be a thought. That’s what distinguishes the guy who suddenly hates you from the guy who’s thrown into you by a bumpy bit of track.

But now imagine there’s someone else on the train—say, someone in a hurry to get to an interview. As soon as the train stops, she rushes out the door and bumps into you on the way. The first hater-guy was aggressive on purpose, but what about this person? It sure sounds like she intended to bump into you: she moved her body through space, in a particular trajectory, that trajectory collided with your body, and she followed that trajectory deliberately. In other words, she deliberately ran into you.

So here’s where Anscombe has a really interesting insight. She says that there are lots of ways of describing an action, and whether or not you did something intentionally depends on how you think about it. Her most famous example starts with a fellow putting water into a well, and that water goes into a house. He sounds like a helpful guy, doesn't he. Except it turns out that water is poisoned—suddenly he's not so helpful. But then we find out the people in the house are Nazis!

Confused? Well, Anscombe’s point is that we can describe what he’s doing in four different ways: he’s putting water in a well; he’s supplying water to the house; he’s poisoning people; he’s killing Nazis. Which one is his real intention? Is it all of them? Well, imagine he doesn’t know the people in the house are Nazis. In that case, he only intends to poison some random people, not to kill a bunch of Nazis—that sure seems very different.

So what does this tell us about the woman in the train? She also did something that can ben seen in many different ways: she ran toward a door; she rushed to get to her interview; she bumped into a literature professor. Her action looks very different depending on how you describe it. And in particular, she only intended some of it—she certainly never meant to spoil anyone's day. Of course, our poisoner didn’t know who was in the house, whereas the woman on the train had all the facts in front of her: she saw you standing right there, so in some sense she jostled you on purpose. But what if she was just doing the best she could? After all, her main intention was to get that cool job she was interviewing for. Well, Anscombe rules that kind of thing out: you can’t intend to get a cool job, since getting a job depends on other people and isn’t entirely up to you.

So where does that leave us? In the capable hands of our Anscombe-expert guest, Rachael Wiseman, author of The Routledge Guidebook to Anscombe’s 'Intention'.

Comments (13)


royalgame's picture

royalgame

Thursday, January 9, 2025 -- 12:28 PM

Royal X Casino Download

Royal X Casino Download Latest Version Free For Android. Royal x casino download free play games and earn money online in Pakistan.
https://royalxcasino.biz/

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Jancornwell21's picture

Jancornwell21

Friday, January 10, 2025 -- 10:19 PM

When it comes to finding a

When it comes to finding a dependable Roblox script executor, think of tools like Synapse X that align perfectly with dress to impress codes. It stands out for its stability, ease of use, and ability to enhance gameplay through tailored features and automation, making it a top choice for many players seeking a seamless and customizable experience. Visit http://dresstoimpress-codes.com.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
philosopher's picture

philosopher

Sunday, January 12, 2025 -- 3:49 AM

I agree, Anscombe is very

I agree, Anscombe is very interesting philosopher. You can find my stuff at Metaphysicians' Journal.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Daniel's picture

Daniel

Monday, January 13, 2025 -- 3:24 PM

Individual intention

Individual intention underdetermined by recognition of the range of contribution-variants to its success indicates an argument for reduction of effect authorship where claims of optional determination are made. If someone goes fishing and catches a fish, for example, the intention to do so plays a relatively small role in the final result. But as I read the argument this applies to much more exclusive contexts such as painting a picture or writing a novel, which produces a tension between considerations of general causes, a stream's accessible location perhaps, in the fishing example, and particular causes, e.g. the use of a different kind of lure after many failed attempts with an alternate.

In another example, the event of climate change constitutes a generic or general cause of wildfires in forested areas, but not a particular cause of any single wildfire event. By inclusion of both in reference to the same effect-determination, an increase in reference intension of factor-quantity (the general cause), is seen to be a decrease in reference-extension of factor-quality (the particular cause). Insofar as the former is described as singular, an optional constraint is placed on it so that a causal regress does not obtain which would hinder practical action. Would this for Anscombe make an Idealism of logical form (i.e. rule-variant) become a Realism of anthropological matter? Does a limit to causal regress in etiological judgement imply a release of effect progress in sociological prescript?

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
LatoyaMartinez's picture

LatoyaMartinez

Monday, January 13, 2025 -- 6:04 PM

Immersing yourself in the fun

Immersing yourself in the fun space in merge fruit will bring you a feeling of excitement when playing as well as help your thinking be flexible when having to think of putting the pieces together.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
melmedarda's picture

melmedarda

Saturday, January 18, 2025 -- 5:37 AM

How does Anscombe's theory of

How does Anscombe's theory of intentionality account for actions that have both intended and unintended consequences, and how does this relate to our moral responsibility for those consequences?

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
melmedarda's picture

melmedarda

Sunday, January 19, 2025 -- 5:35 PM

Love the Chill Guy Meme? This

Love the Chill Guy Meme? This game brings it to life with fun gameplay and amazing visuals! Chill Guy Clicker

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
hfd6yyu's picture

hfd6yyu

Sunday, January 19, 2025 -- 7:57 PM

Eye of Rah : the Viral Meme

Eye of Rah : the Viral Meme That’s Taking Over TikTok
In the ever-evolving landscape of internet humor, a new meme has emerged, captivating audiences and dominating social media feeds. Known as the “Eye of Rah,” this viral sensation features a distinctive image of Rashad Bowens, a TikToker known as @lilbotheme, digitally altered to possess a single, cyclopean eye and a solitary red dreadlock standing erect.

The meme’s genesis can be traced back to another TikTok and Instagram user, Jeremiah Springfield. Inspired by the “Hood Cryptids” trend, Springfield took a video of Bowens, who is popular for his reaction stitches and unique red hair that often defies gravity, and transformed it into something bizarrely fascinating. The result? An image where Bowens sports a single, all-seeing eye and a hairstyle reminiscent of a flickering flame. This edit quickly became the defining visual of the “Eye of Rah” meme.

“Ay, yo, chill the fuck out, yo,” Bowens exclaims in the original video that served as the raw material for Springfield’s creation. This phrase has also become somewhat associated with the meme. However, it’s the striking visual, more than anything else, which propelled “Eye of Rah” into the viral stratosphere in early January 2025.

The Eye of Ra phenomenon exemplifies a broader trend in online content characterized by “brain rot” and “sludge.” These terms describe videos and memes that are often nonsensical, surreal, and difficult to explain to those outside the immediate online community. They represent a form of humor that thrives on absurdity and the rapid-fire blending of different meme formats. Indeed, “Eye of Rah” is frequently mashed up with other trending memes of the time, such as “Chopped Chin” and “I Bought a Property in Egypt,” further contributing to the chaotic and engaging nature of this online trend.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
karan115's picture

karan115

Friday, January 31, 2025 -- 11:24 PM

I agree

I agree

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
fool's picture

fool

Tuesday, February 4, 2025 -- 6:13 AM

Teen Patti Lucky Pakistan is

Teen Patti Lucky Pakistan is a popular online card game that offers players the chance to win real money while enjoying a virtual poker-like experience. The game, based on the traditional Indian card game of "Teen Patti," features three cards dealt to each player, with betting rounds and strategies determining the winner. In Teen Patti Lucky Pakistan, players can compete against others and use in-game currency to place bets. The platform often offers bonuses, promotions, and a social environment for friends to join together. It's enjoyed by many who like card games and are looking for an exciting gambling experience.

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines
Liamdawson's picture

Liamdawson

Thursday, February 6, 2025 -- 11:59 PM

Jacket Attire is an amazing

Jacket Attire is an amazing option to fulfill your dreams of fashionable outfits, and with the help of the Christmas Sale, Halloween Deals, and many others, you can get your next ideal outfit at just a pocket-friendly price. Jacket Attire

I've read and agree to abide by the Community Guidelines